She's
a 40-year-old mother of eight, with a ninth child due soon. The family
homestead in a Burundi village is too small to provide enough food, and
three of the children have quit school for lack of money to pay required
fees.
"I regret to have made all those children," says Godelive Ndageramiwe. "If I were to start over, I would only make two or three."
At Ahmed Kasadha's prosperous farm in eastern Uganda, it's a different story.
"My
father had 25 children I have only 14 so far, and expect to produce
more in the future," says Kasadha, who has two wives. He considers a
large family a sign of success and a guarantee of support in his old
age.
By the time Ndageramiwe's ninth child arrives, and any further members of the Kasadha clan, the world's population
will have passed a momentous milestone. As of Oct. 31, according to the
U.N. Population Fund, there will be 7 billion people sharing Earth's
land and resources.
In Western
Europe, Japan and Russia, it will be an ironic milestone amid worries
about low birthrates and aging populations. In China and India, the two most populous nations, it's an occasion to reassess policies that have already slowed once-rapid growth.
But
in Burundi, Uganda and the rest of sub-Saharan Africa, the demographic
news is mostly sobering as the region staggers under the double burden
of the world's highest birthrates and deepest poverty. The regional
population of nearly 900 million could reach 2 billion in 40 years at
current rates, accounting for about half of the projected global
population growth over that span.
"Most of that growth will be in
Africa's cities, and in those cities it will almost all be in slums
where living conditions are horrible," said John Bongaarts of the
Population Council, a New York-based research organization.
Is
catastrophe inevitable? Not necessarily. But experts say most of Africa
and other high-growth developing nations such as Afghanistan and
Pakistan will be hard-pressed to furnish enough food, water and jobs
for their people, especially without major new family-planning
initiatives.
"Extreme poverty and large families tend to reinforce
each other," says Lester Brown, the environmental analyst who heads the
Earth Policy Institute in Washington. "The challenge is to intervene in
that cycle and accelerate the shift to smaller families."
Without such intervention, Brown says, food and water shortages could fuel political destabilization in developing regions.
"There's
quite a bit of land that could produce food if we had the water to go
with it," he said. "It's water that's becoming the real constraint."
The
International Water Management Institute shares these concerns,
predicting that by 2025 about 1.8 billion people will live in places
suffering from severe water scarcity.
According to demographers,
the world's population didn't reach 1 billion until 1804, and it took
123 years to hit the 2 billion mark in 1927. Then the pace accelerated
3 billion in 1959, 4 billion in 1974, 5 billion in 1987, 6 billion in
1998.
Looking ahead, the U.N. projects that the world population
will reach 8 billion by 2025, 10 billion by 2083. But the numbers could
be much higher or lower, depending on such factors as access to birth
control, infant mortality rates and average life expectancy which has
risen from 48 years in 1950 to 69 years today.
"Overall, this is
not a cause for alarm the world has absorbed big gains since 1950,"
said Bongaarts, a vice president of the Population Council. But he
cautioned that strains are intensifying: rising energy and food prices,
environmental stresses, more than 900 million people undernourished.
"For the rich, it's totally manageable," Bongaarts said. "It's the poor, everywhere, who will be hurt the most."
The
executive director of the U.N. Population Fund, former Nigerian health
minister Babatunde Osotimehin, describes the 7 billion milestone as a
call to action especially in the realm of enabling adolescent girls to
stay in school and empowering women to control the number of children
they have.
"It's an opportunity to bring the issues of population,
women's rights and family planning back to center stage," he said in an
interview. "There are 215 million women worldwide who need family
planning and don't get it. If we can change that, and these women can
take charge of their lives, we'll have a better world."
But as
Osotimehin noted, population-related challenges vary dramatically around
the world. Associated Press reporters on four continents examined some
of most distinctive examples:
___
THE ASIAN GIANTS
It's
6 p.m. in Mumbai, India's financial hub, and millions of workers swarm
out of their offices, headed to railway stations for a ride home. Every
few minutes, as a train enters the station, the crowd surges forward.
For
nearly 7 million commuters who ride the overtaxed suburban rail network
each work day, every ride is a scramble. Each car is jam-packed;
sometimes, riders die when they lose their foothold while clinging to
the doors.
Across India, the teeming slums, congested streets, and
crowded trains and trams are testimony to the country's burgeoning
population. Already the second most populous country, with 1.2 billion
people, India is expected to overtake China around 2030 when its
population soars to an estimated 1.6 billion.
But even as the
numbers increase, the pace of the growth has slowed. Demographers say
India's fertility rate now 2.6 children per woman should fall to 2.1
by 2025 and to 1.8 by 2035.
More than half of India's population
is under 25, and some policy planners say this so-called "youth
dividend" could fuel a productive surge over the next few decades. But
population experts caution that the dividend could prove to be a
liability without vast social investments.
"If the young population remains uneducated, unskilled and unemployable, then that dividend would be wasted," says Shereen Jejeebhoy, a Population Council demographer in New Delhi.
Population
experts also worry about a growing gender gap, stemming largely from
Indian families' preference for sons. A surge in sex-selection tests,
resulting in abortion of female fetuses, has skewed the ratio, with the
latest census showing 914 girls under age 6 for every 1,000 boys.
Family
planning is a sensitive issue. In the 35 years since one government was
toppled for pursuing an aggressive population control program,
subsequent leaders have been reluctant to follow suit.
For now,
China remains the most populous nation, with 1.34 billion people. In the
past decade it added 73.9 million, more than the population of France
or Thailand.
Nonetheless, its growth has slowed dramatically and
the population is projected to start shrinking in 2027. By 2050,
according to some demographers, it will be smaller than it is today.
"It's
like a train on the track that's still moving but the engine is already
off," says Gu Baochang, a professor of demography at Beijing's Renmin
University.
In the 1970s, Chinese women had five to six children
each on average. Today China has a fertility rate the number of
children the average woman is expected to have in her lifetime of
around 1.5, well below the 2.1 replacement rate that demographers say is
needed to keep populations stable in developed countries.
Three
decades of strict family planning rules that limit urban families to one
child and rural families to two helped China achieve a rapid decline in
fertility but the policy has brought problems as well.
Before long, there will be too few young Chinese people to easily support a massive elderly population.
Also,
as with India, there's a gender gap. The United Nations says there are
43 million "missing girls" in China because parents restricted to small
families often favored sons and aborted girls after learning their
unborn babies' gender through sonograms.
"China is always so proud
of how quickly we brought down fertility from high to low, and how many
births were avoided but I think we did it too quickly and reduced it to
too low a level," says Gu. "I wish that India can learn this: 'Don't
make it too quick.'"
___
WESTERN EUROPE AND THE U.S.
Spain
used to give parents 2,500 euros (more than $3,000) for every newborn
child to encourage families to reverse the country's low birth rate. But
the checks stopped coming with Spain's austerity measures, raising the
question of who will pay the bills to support the elderly in the years
ahead.
It's a question bedeviling many European countries which
have grappled for years over how to cope with shrinking birth rates and
aging populations and are now faced with a financial crisis that has
forced some to cut back on family-friendly government incentives.
Spain
and Italy, both forced to enact painful austerity measures in a bid to
narrow budget deficits, are battling common problems: Women have chosen
to have their first child at a later age, and the difficulties of
finding jobs and affordable housing are discouraging some couples from
having any children at all.
In 2010, for the fourth consecutive
year, more Italians died than were born, according to the national
statistics agency. Italy's population nonetheless grew slightly to 60.6
million due to immigration, which is a highly charged issue across
Europe.
Italy's youth minister Giorgia Meloni said earlier this
year that measures to reverse the birth rate require "millions in
investment" but that the resources aren't available.
Unlike many
countries in Europe, France's population is growing slightly but
steadily every year. It has one of the highest birth rates in the
European Union with around 2 children per woman.
One reason is
immigration to France by Africans with large-family traditions, but it's
also due to family-friendly legislation. The government offers public
preschools, subsidies to all families that have more than one child,
generous maternity leave, and tax exemptions for employers of nannies.
Like
France, the United States has one of the highest population growth
rates among industrialized nations. Its fertility rate is just below the
replacement rate of 2.1 children per woman, but its population has been
increasing by almost 1 percent annually due to immigration. With 312
million people, the U.S. is the third most populous country after China
and India.
___
AFRICA
Lagos, Nigeria, is expected to
overtake Cairo soon as Africa's largest city. Private water vendors
there do a brisk business in the many neighborhoods that otherwise lack
access to potable water.
The drone of generators is omnipresent,
at offices and markets, in neighborhoods rich and poor, because the
power grid doesn't produce enough power. Periodic blackouts extend for
hours, days, sometimes weeks.
Such is daily life in Nigeria's
commercial capital, where the population is estimated at 15 million and
growing at 6 percent or more each year. Problems with traffic
congestion, sanitation and water supplies are staggering; a recent
article in UN-Habitat said two-thirds of the residents live in poverty.
The
rest of Nigeria isn't growing as fast estimates of its growth rate
range from 2 percent to 3.2 percent. But it's already Africa's most
populous country with more than 160 million people.
Ndyanabangi
Bannet, the U.N. Population Fund's deputy representative in Nigeria,
notes that 60 percent of the population is under 30 and needs to be
accommodated with education, training and health care.
"It is a
plus if it is taken advantage of," he said of Nigeria's youth. "But if
it is not harnessed, it can be a challenge, because imagine what hordes
of unemployed young people can do."
In Uganda, another
fast-growing country, President Yoweri Museveni used to be disdainful of
population control and urged Ugandans, especially in rural areas, to
continue having large families.
Recently, the government has
conceded that its 3.2 population growth rate must be curbed because the
economy can't keep pace. Earlier this year, anti-government protests by
unemployed youths and other aggrieved Ugandans flared in several
communities, and nine marchers were killed in confrontations with
police.
"The government has been convinced that unless it invests
in reproductive health, Uganda is destined to a crisis," says Hannington
Burunde of the Uganda Population Secretariat.
Among those who are struggling is John Baliruno, 45, of Mpigi in central Uganda, a father of nine.
"I
never intended to have such a big number," he said. "I with my wife had
no knowledge of family planning and ended up producing one child after
another. Now I cannot properly feed them."
Looking ahead, he's pessimistic.
"The
environment is being destroyed by the growing population. Trees are
being cut down in big numbers and even now we can't get enough firewood
to cook food," he said. "In the near future, we will starve."
Another
of the fastest-growing countries is Burundi. With roughly 8.6 million
people, it's the second most densely populated African country after
neighboring Rwanda.
Omer Ndayishimiye, head of Burundi's
Population Department, said continued high growth coincides with
dwindling natural resources. Land suitable for farming will decline, and
poverty will be rampant, he said, noting that 90 percent of the
population live in rural areas and rely on farming to survive.
The
government has been trying to raise awareness about the demographic
challenges among the clergy, civic leaders and the general public.
"We
are suggesting couples to go to health clinics to get taught different
birth control methods," Ndayishimiye said. "But we are facing some
barriers ... Many Burundians still see children as source of wealth."
At her modest house in Gishubi, Godelive Ndageramiwe ponders the changes that have made her regret her large family.
"Children
were a good labor force in the past when there was enough space to
cultivate," she said. "Today I can't even feed my family properly. My
kids just spend days doing nothing."
After her fourth child, she began to worry how her family could be cared for.
"But
my husband was against birth control and wanted as many children as
possible," she said. "It was delicate because he could marry another
wife.
"My friends advised me to
go to a nearby clinic, but I was told I must come with my husband. Now I
have laid the issue in the hands of God."
___
David
Crary reported from New York. Associated Press writers Alexa Oleson in
Beijing, Nirmala George in New Delhi, Angela Charlton in Paris, Daniel
Woolls in Madrid, Victor Simpson in Rome, Onesime Niyungeko in
Bujumbura, Burundi; Yinka Ibukun in Lagos, Nigeria, and Godfrey Olukya
in Kampala, Uganda, also contributed
Britain's rioters: young, poor and disillusioned
By MEERA SELVA - Associated Press,PAISLEY DODDS - Associated Press | AP 11.08.2011.
FILE -Youths throw bricks at police in this Sunday, Aug. 7, 2011 photo during unrest
LONDON
(AP) Each of the young rioters who clogged Britain's courthouses
painted a bleak picture of a lost generation: a 15-year-old Ukrainian
whose mother died, a 17-year-old who followed his cousin into the
mayhem, an 11-year-old arrested for stealing a garbage can.
Britain
is bitterly divided on the reasons behind the riots. Some blame the
unrest on opportunistic criminality, while others say conflicting
economic policies and punishing government spending cuts have deepened
inequalities in the country's most deprived areas.
Many
of the youths themselves struggle to find any plausible answer, but a
widespread sense of alienation emerges from their tales.
"Nobody
is doing nothing for us not the politicians, not the cops, no one," a
19-year-old who lives near Tottenham, the blighted London neighborhood
where the riots started. He only gave his nickname, "Freddy," because he
took part in the looting and was scared of facing prosecution; he was
not among the youths in court.
Britain
has one of the highest violent crime rates in the EU. Roughly 18
percent of youths between 16 and 24 are jobless and nearly half of all
black youths are out of work.
As
the government battles colossal government debt with harsh welfare cuts
that promise to make the futures of these youths even bleaker, some
experts say it's narrow-minded to believe the riots have only been a
random outburst of violence unrelated to the current economic crisis.
"There's
a fundamental disconnect with a particular section of young Britain and
sections of the political establishment," said Matthew Goodwin, a
politics professor at University of Nottingham.
"The
argument that this doesn't have anything to do with expenditure cuts or
economics doesn't stand up to the evidence. If that's true, then what
we have here are hundreds of young, crazed kids simply acting
irrationally. I don't think that's the case."
Nearly
1,200 people have been arrested since the riots erupted Saturday,
mostly poor youths from a broad section of Britain's many races and
ethnicities.
Courts have been
running nearly 24 hours a day to hear all the cases since the rioting
began. Most cases are heard in a blink of an eye and only give a
snapshot of some of the youngsters' lives. Many of the defendants
haven't had a chance to talk at length with their attorneys, and most
can't be named because they are minors.
An
11-year-old boy from Romford, Essex, was among one of the youngest to
appear in court on Wednesday. Wearing a blue Adidas tracksuit, the
youngster spoke only to confirm his name, age and date of birth.
The boy pleaded guilty to burglary, after stealing a waste bin worth 50 pounds. A charge of violent disorder was dropped.
Attorneys
for some of the defendants said their clients were good kids who have
caring families but got caught up in the violence.
Daniel
Cavaglieri, one of the lawyers for a 17-year-old who appeared at
Highbury Magistrates Court, said the youth was studying mechanics and
trying to finish school. He was accused of following his older cousin to
loot a clothing shop, and charged with intent to steal.
"His
mother is furious he was out and about at that time. She genuinely
thought he was at a friend's house," Cavaglieri told the court. "He's
going to be grounded."
Another
defendant, a 15-year-old immigrant from Ukraine, pleaded not guilty to
using or threatening unlawful violence. He already has a criminal record
for theft, and police said he threw stones and other missiles in the
thick of Tuesday's rioting in London's Hackney area.
Prosecutors
said the boy is an only child who lives with his widowed father. He
came to Britain from Germany three years ago after leaving Ukraine when
his mother died.
It's unclear what role racial tensions have played in the riots, if any.
In
Tottenham, most residents are white but blacks from Africa or the
Caribbean account for around a quarter of the ethnic mix. It's also home
to Indian, Pakistani, Bangladeshi and Asian immigrants. The rage has
appeared to cut across ethnic lines, with poverty as the main common
denominator.
But there's a
history of racial tension in many of these neighborhoods, and the riots
themselves were triggered by the fatal police shooting of a black man in
Tottenham.
In 1985, the
neighborhood was home to the Broadwater Farm riot, an event seared in
the memories of many of the rioters' parents. Back then, violence
exploded area when a black woman died from a stroke during a police
search. The area remains a hotbed of ethnic tension: In the past year,
police have logged some 100 racist or religion based hate crimes.
Other social problems afflict the places where rioting erupted: high teen pregnancy rates, gun crime and drug trafficking.
Under
the Labour-led government of Prime Minister Tony Blair, authorities
tried to penalize badly behaved youth with Anti-Social Behavior Orders,
or ASBOs. The orders have since become badges of honor for many of
Britain's youth.
In 2008, there
were more than 1 million reported cases of violent crimes in England and
Wales alone. By comparison, there were 331,778 reported incidents in
France and some 210,885 incidents in Germany. Violent crime carried out
by children and teenagers is also among the highest in Europe.
"There's
income inequality, extremely high levels of unemployment between 16 and
24-year-olds and huge parts of this population not in education or
training," Goodwin said. "There's a general malaise amongst a particular
generation."
Britain's
Conservative-led government is implementing painful austerity measures
in an attempt to get the country's finances in order. Prime Minister
David Cameron has pledged 80 billion pounds ($129 billion) of spending
cuts and 30 billion pounds in extra taxes to trim Britain's huge
deficit, swollen after the government spent billions bailing out
foundering banks.
The plans to
cut services from welfare to education sparked violent protests last
year, as students took to the streets to demonstrate against the
tripling of university fees. The government is also cutting civil
service jobs and benefits, raising the state pension age from 65 to 66,
hiking the amount public sector employees contribute to pensions and
reducing their retirement payouts.
The
austerity measures will also slash housing benefit payments used to
subsidize rents for the low-paid, threatening to price tens of thousands
of poor families out of their homes and force them toward the fringes
of the country's capital.
Economists
at the Centre for Economic Policy Research say such cuts promise more
unrest. Most of Britain's deepest cuts haven't even come yet.
"There's
usually something that sparks these things off," said Hans-Joachim
Voth, a research fellow at the center. "The question is why is it that
in 90 percent of these cases that nothing happens? Why is it that some
places just end up like a tinder box?"
___
Gabriele Steinhauser in Brussels and Cassandra Vinograd in London contributed to this report.
Japan to dig site linked to WWII human experiments
Updated: 2011-02-20 21:08 (Agencies)
TOKYO - Japan is starting to excavate the site of a former medical school that may reveal grisly secrets from World War II.
The investigation begins Monday at the former school linked to Unit
731, a germ and biological warfare outfit during the war. Shadowy
experiments conducted by the unit on war prisoners have never been
officially acknowledged by the government but have been documented by
historians and participants.
It is the first government probe of the Tokyo site, and follows a
former nurse's revelation that she helped bury body parts there as
American forces began occupying the capital at the end of the war.
Health Ministry official Kazuhiko Kawauchi said the excavation is aimed at finding out if anything is buried in the plot.
"We are not certain if the survey will find anything," Kawauchi
said. "If anything is dug up, it may not be related to Unit 731."
The former nurse, Toyo Ishii, now 88, broke 60 years of silence in
2006, saying she and colleagues at an army hospital at the site were
ordered to bury numerous corpses, bones and body parts during the weeks
following Japan's August 15, 1945, surrender before American troops
arrived in the capital.
Her disclosure led to a face-to-face meeting with the health
minister and a government pledge to investigate. The digging had to wait
until the scheduled relocation of residents and the demolition of
apartments on the site last year.
The site is close to another area where a mass grave of dozens of
possible war-experiment victims was uncovered in 1989 during the
construction of a Health Ministry research institute.
Any remains found at the planned excavation site would have a
stronger connection to Unit 731, said Keiichi Tsuneishi, a Kanagawa
University history professor and expert on biological warfare.
"The site used to be the research headquarters of Unit 731,"
Tsuneishi said. "If bones are found there, they are most likely related
to Unit 731."
From its wartime base in Japanese-controlled Harbin in northern
China, Unit 731 and related units injected war prisoners with typhus,
cholera and other diseases to research germ warfare, according to
historians and former unit members. Unit 731 also is believed to have
performed vivisections and to have frozen prisoners to death in
endurance tests.
The 1989 find revealed dozens of fragmented thigh bones and skulls,
some with holes drilled in them or sections cut out. Police denied
there was any evidence of criminal activity.
The ministry concluded that the bones could not be directly linked
to Unit 731. It said the remains were mostly of non-Japanese Asians and
were likely from bodies used in "medical education" or brought back from
the war zone for analysis at the medical school.
Spain's salad growers are modern-day slaves, say charities
Investigation uncovers plight of migrant workers who live in appalling conditions and are paid half of legal minimum wage
The Costa del Sol is famous for its tourists and beaches but just
behind them is a hidden world of industrial greenhouses where African
migrants work in extreme conditions Link to this video
The exploitation of tens of thousands of migrants used to grow salad vegetables for British supermarkets has been uncovered by a Guardian investigation into the 2bn-a-year (ฃ1.6bn) hothouse industry in southern Spain.
Charities
working with illegal workers during this year's harvest claim the
abuses meet the UN's official definition of modern-day slavery,
with some workers having their pay withheld for complaining. Conditions
appear to have deteriorated further as the collapse of the Spanish
property boom has driven thousands of migrants from construction to
horticulture to look for work.
The Guardian's findings include:
Migrant workers from Africa living in shacks made of old boxes and
plastic sheeting, without sanitation or access to drinking water.
Wages that are routinely less than half the legal minimum wage.
Workers without papers being told they will be reported to the police if they complain.
Allegations of segregation enforced by police harassment when African
workers stray outside the hothouse areas into tourist areas.
The
situation of migrants working in the tomato, pepper, cucumber and
courgette farms of Almeria is so desperate that the Red Cross has been
handing out free food
to thousands of them. Its local co-ordinator described conditions as
"inhuman". Anti-Slavery International said the Guardian's evidence was
"deeply disturbing", and raised the "spectre of de facto state
sanctioning of slavery in 21st century Europe".
Mohammed's story is typical of thousands of Africans working under the sweltering heat of plastic greenhouses.
He
arrived illegally in southern Spain from Morocco in 2004 to work in the
hothouses, having paid 1,000 to smugglers to bring him in a fishing
boat. He said back then he could earn 30 for an eight-hour day. Now
he's lucky to get 20 a day.
The legal minimum wage for a day's
work is currently more than 44, but the economic crisis has created a
newly enlarged surplus of migrants desperate for work, enabling farmers
to slash wages.
Mohammed's home is a shack in the hothouse area
that runs into the tourist town of Roquetas de Mar on the Costa del Sol.
It is crudely knocked together from the wooden pallets used to
transport the crops and covered with a layer of old agricultural
plastic. There is no drinking water or sanitation.
There are 100
or so shacks like this next to Mohammed's. Jobs are sporadic, and come
not with contracts but by the day or even by the hour. Sometimes, when
he and his compatriots have been without work for weeks, there is no
food, unless the Red Cross makes one of its food parcel deliveries. "We
live like animals scavenging. No work, no money, no food," he said.
Jawara
came from Gambia in 2008 with 85 others who were packed like cargo on a
small fishing boat. He felt lucky to have survived the trauma of the
journey; some of those with him drowned or died on the boat. Released
from detention after 40 days to go and find work, he now lives with 10
others from Sub-Saharan Africa in an abandoned farm building among the
hothouses near the Almerian market town San Isidro.
The men sleep
in the part that still has the semblance of a roof. They are crammed
into three small rooms that are sour with the smell of dampness and
stale food, the walls blackened by the camping stove they use to cook.
The bathroom is the outbuilding next door, its roof long gone and its
bricks reduced to rubble. The sitting room is a salvaged sofa leaning
against broken walls. There is no sanitation here either and the men
live in between the farm jobs they find on the tomato crop, charity
handouts and Red Cross parcels.
Jawara came to San Isidroto to
join his brother and had just three months of reunion with him before
his brother died from kidney problems. Without papers, they had been too
frightened to go to the doctor and they couldn't afford medicines. His
father died too while he has been away. Like many of those we
interviewed Jawerea spoke of his shame at the conditions, the racism he
encountered everywhere and how little they are now paid. He did not want
to be filmed in case his family back home saw how he lived.
Sang,
also from Gambia, considers himself relatively well off sharing an
abandoned farmhouse with about 40 others from west Africa. A local
farmer rents it to them illegally, as although it has a roof and
electricity, it has no running water.
In addition to rent, the
migrants must pay 600 a month to have a tanker deliver water to an old
borehole in the yard. Sang, who has been supporting about 30 family
members in Gambia with his wages, has also been reduced to working a few
hours at a time on the salad harvest in the past year, as the recession
hit.
Almeria used to be Spain's poorest region but the boom in
horticulture since the late 1980s has helped transform the area, which
sits just behind the Costa del Sol. Although British holidaymakers
rarely see it, less than a mile from the tourist hotels on the beach a
vast industrial landscape of plastic hothouses has taken over 400 square
km of the coastal plain.
The trade in vegetables grown in the
region meets UK demand for all year-round fresh salad. It is worth 2bn a
year to the Spanish economy, according to Jos้ มngel Aznar, professor
of applied economics at the university of Almeria. Nearly all the
leading retailers across northern Europe, including British
supermarkets, source salad crops from the region when their own season
ends. They buy at auction from the co-operatives to which the farmers
belong.
But the boom has only been possible thanks to migrants.
The hothouses have needed a large supply of cheap labour that can be
turned on and off at a moment's notice. The work is irregular and
arduous, and with temperatures reaching 40C-45C is unattractive to the
local population. So it has sucked in thousands of illegal workers,
first from Morocco, then from eastern Europe and sub-Saharan Africa.
Estimates
of the total number working in the hothouses vary, but Juan Carlos
Checa, researcher in social anthropology at the university, put the
number of migrant workers in April 2010 at 80,000-90,000.
Spitou
Mendy, who was himself an illegal migrant from Senegal until he gained
his papers in an amnesty, now helps run Sindicato de Obreros del Campo
(SOC), a small union for migrants. He thinks the numbers have swollen to
more than 100,000 due to the recession.
The Spanish government
allows those who can prove they have worked for more than three years to
apply to become regularised and many have done so, but tens of
thousands are still in Almeria illegally, making them easy to exploit.
Conditions that were already appalling have deteriorated further in the
past two years, according to Mendy.
Farmers argue that the
supermarkets have squeezed their margins even harder during the
downturn, while costs for fuel and fertiliser have gone up. They have no
choice but to cut wages, which is the one element of their production
costs they can control. Farmers trying to employ people legally and at
the proper rate find it hard to compete or make a profit.
In
Mendy's eyes the conditions are slavery. "You don't find the sons of
Spain in the hothouses, only the blacks and people from former
colonies," he says. "The farmers only want an unqualified, malleable
workforce, which costs absolutely nothing. Only one part of the business
is benefiting from this. It's the big agribusiness that wins. It's the
capitalists that win. And humanity is killed that way. This is slavery
in Europe. At the door to Europe, there is slavery as if we were in the
16th century."
Cherif, who used to be a teacher of French and
German in Senegal but now supports two children on what he earns picking
tomatoes a few days a month, has found farmers only too happy to take
advantage of illegal workers. "You have to shut your mouth about the
conditions. It's very, very hot; there's no water to drink and it's
back-breaking. They pay me only 20-25 a day and I don't feel free. The
police watch me if I go to the wrong places."
Like many we spoke
to, Cherif had experience of farmers refusing to pay for work that had
been done. "One farmer didn't want to pay me and another African. He
owed me 200. The other man had a fight with him and got his money but I
didn't want to fight. So I walked to his house every day for two months
until he gave it to me, but even then he shortchanged me by 5."
Tensions
between migrants and local communities have been growing in recent
months. SOC fears a repeat of the violence and rioting that occurred in
2000, in the horticultural town of El Ejido. Mendy explained that they
had seen the warning signs in San Isidro last October when a farmer was
murdered in his hothouse store and locals immediately pointed the finger
at migrants. Thousands protested in the streets following his funeral,
brandishing racist placards picturing Africans as black sheep and
saying: "Immigrants: behave or get out". It later transpired that the
police were investigating the farmer's links to organised crime.
Most
of the time the two communities are completely segregated, however. The
only black people seen in tourist areas are a few hawkers selling
trinkets on the beaches, while Africans and Moroccans live hidden away
in slums among the hothouses. They come into the agricultural towns at
daybreak to queue by main roads for casual work, but are expected to
melt away afterwards. Several of those we interviewed described being
harassed by police if they strayed outside the hothouse areas at other
times.
Sister Purification, or Puri, as she is known, is one of
four Catholic nuns from the order of the Merciful Sisters of Charity who
live in San Isidro. She recalled how the first black Africans had come
to the town in 2002.
The detention centres in the Canaries that
received migrants arriving illegally in boats from Africa were full. In
order to process new arrivals, the Spanish authorities began flying
those already there out to mainland airports to disperse them to areas
where labour was needed. They hired a coach to take about 30 Africans
from Madrid airport to the centre of San Isidro, where the driver was
instructed to open the doors in Plaza Colonizaci๓n, the main square, and
simply release them. "That was the first time black people came here.
"The
government gave them absolutely nothing; no money, no papers, nothing,
just told them, off you go. No one here knew they were coming. The local
authorities washed their hands of them. The people in the town didn't
want anything to do with them. We had no idea what to do," Puri
explained.
In the end, the nuns took the African men to a disused
hothouse. Others began arriving and started building cardboard hovels
under its dilapidated structure, until more than 300 people were living
there in a makeshift slum without sanitation. "The conditions were
terrible, horrible, not human," Puri recalled.
As more and more
people came, the nuns began to worry about health problems. They found
TB, Aids and hepatitis among the migrants, but knew they couldn't get
proper medical help. They began taking those who were ill to abandoned
farmhouses nearby to isolate them from the rest. "We didn't have the
means to provide more. The government was doing next to nothing."
Then
in September 2005 a huge fire broke out. Hundreds of Africans were
driven out of the slum as the plastic burned. The fire brigade and
police arrived, but once the fire was out they just left again and
refused to help, according to Puri.
The nuns used their own small
cars to begin distributing about 300 plus men, to places they knew
migrants were already sheltering in the area in old farm buildings and
underground wells. But by 2am, there were still 120 men with nowhere to
go and it was decided that they should sleep in the main square, with
the nuns accompanying them for solidarity. "We were there three days.
The town did nothing. The government did nothing. I was crying with
rage, with impotence and with indignation," says Puri.
Today the
nuns run a feeding centre where they hand out food and clothes to
migrants. They have more than 4,000 recipients registered on their
computer in this one small agricultural community of 7,000 inhabitants
alone.
"There have been five deaths of migrants in the last year
here from traffic accidents at night," Puri added. "About 18 months ago
an African worker died in one of the hothouses he had fallen into the
water tank and couldn't get out. There was no punishment for the farmer,
no police questions," Puri told us. "I am very conscious what we are
doing is not a real solution. But they know that at least if they are
sick or desperate, we are here to hold their hand."
The conditions
are not just confined to Almeria. As the olive harvest was about to
begin just before last Christmas in the region of Ja้n, thousands of
migrants moved there desperately trying to find work. With no money and
no shelter, most were being fed once a day at a centre run by the Red
Cross. They were allowed to stay at the centre for three days but then
had to leave. Most were sleeping rough. Those with papers could apply
for a free bus pass at the Red Cross centre each morning to get
themselves to the olive groves to tout for work.
The Red Cross in
Jaen did not return our calls but its co-ordinator in Almeria, Francisco
Vicente, said it estimates that there are between 15,000 and 20,000
homeless migrants in his province alone, of which some 5,000 live in
abandoned houses and shacks without running water or electricity. "These
are more 'established' communities, which the Red Cross can at least
reach. But the others are spread throughout town, sleeping near bank
cash machines, or just on the streets. This is not human," he added.
Mendy
told us there was a conspiracy of silence about the conditions.
"Everyone knows this system exists, this is untamed neoliberalism. But
people have closed their ears to it."
Vincente agreed: "This is
being hidden, people are not interested in making this public. I am not
referring to only politicians. Sometimes it's the society itself the
people who don't stand up," he told us.
The Spanish government's ministry of interior was asked for comment but failed to respond.
Anti-Slavery
International's director, Aidan McQuade, said: "The evidence obtained
by the Guardian suggests we could be seeing the emergence of a new form
of slavery, which is deeply disturbing.
"The fact that the Spanish
authorities have moved irregular migrants to areas of the country where
labour is needed and also where migrant workers are routinely paid half
the legal minimum wage and threatened with deportation for complaining
about their working conditions, establishes a prima facie case of
official collusion in the trafficking of migrant workers to the
agricultural farms of southern Spain.
"This raises the spectre of de facto state sanctioning of slavery in 21st century Europe."
Rio carnival costumes and floats destroyed by fire
Blaze at Samba City complex where dance schools were preparing for parades causes more than ฃ3m damage
Firefighters work to put out a fire at warehouses in Samba City, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Photograph: Felipe Dana/AP
For months, the carnival-mad supporters of Grande Rio, one of Rio de
Janeiro's leading samba schools, have been dreaming of victory.
With
the city's world-famous carnival set to begin on 4 March, Grande Rio's
dancers, designers and musicians were widely tipped to win their first
ever samba parade contest. Decked in the school's green and red colours,
its website carried the slogan: "We will be the champions. Yes we can!"
However,
those dreams appear to have gone up in smoke, after a fierce blaze
ripped through Samba City on Monday, a complex of warehouses in central
Rio where the city's top 12 schools were making their final
preparations.
Stood in front of Grande Rio's warehouse,
transformed into a smoldering tangle of metal and concrete, Cah๊
Rodrigues, the school's artistic director said 98% of his school's
floats and costumes had been destroyed.
"I'm in a state of shock. The penny hasn't dropped yet," Rodrigues said, wiping tears from his eyes.
"Our
school was gearing up to win carnival and I don't know if in 29 days we
can put on a spectacle on the same level as we had hoped. It's all
burned, all destroyed."
Witnesses said the fire began at around
6am and quickly spread through four warehouses, belonging to the Grande
Rio, Portela and Uniใo da Ilha schools, and Liesa, the carnival
organiser.
The flames reportedly raced through the warehouses,
which were packed with sequined costumes and polystyrene statues. A
giant plume of black smoke could be seen for miles around.
Mara
Minchillo, 19, a British gap-year student from Sussex, who is
volunteering at the Samba City with the Salgueiro school, said: "We saw
the smoke from where we are living and thought, 'What's that?'"
In
an interview with a local newspaper, Grande Rio's costume designer,
Paulo Vitor, said the fire had caused an estimated 10m reais (ฃ3.6m) of
damage. Portela's directors said they had lost at least 2,500 costumes.
"It's
terrible all that work and it is gone," said Marco Antonio Mansilha, a
36-year-old costume designer from the Unidos da Tijuca group. "If it
was my school I'd be crying like hell."
Around him about 80
firemen fought to control the blaze. Samba school workers scrambled to
salvage what they could from the blaze. One by one, giant carnival
floats were dragged from the warehouses; first a 6 metre-tall swan with
fluorescent pink and blue wings; then the grimacing skull of a
Tyrannosaurus rex and a raging bull flanked by two armour-clad knights
on horseback.
During a visit to the devastated Samba City, Rio's mayor, Eduardo Paes, vowed that carnival would continue.
"These
schools have something that is the trademark of Rio's carnival: lots of
passion," said Paes, a samba-enthusiast and supporter of the Portela
school.
"I am very sad to see my school's warehouse and these
other beloved schools in this state. But what makes Rio's carnival tick
is the passion of the people from these communities and these people
will put on a great carnival and Rio will carry on living the great
moment it is going through."
"Tourists can be certain that
carnival will go ahead with the same shine as ever," he added. "I am
sure they will parade with enormous passion, with their hearts beating
in their breasts."
Mansilha said Rio's samba schools would now join forces to help those worst hit.
"The whole world is watching. Thousands of tourists are coming," he said. "It's like they say: the show must go on."
Bloody and bruised: the journalist caught in Egypt unrest
The Guardian's man in Cairo tells of his beating and arrest at the hands of the security forces
In the streets around Abdel Munim Riyad square the atmosphere had
changed. The air which had held a carnival-like vibe was now thick with
teargas. Thousands of people were running out of nearby Tahrir Square
and towards me. Several hundred regrouped; a few dozen protesters set
about attacking an abandoned police truck, eventually tipping it over
and setting it ablaze. Through the smoke, lines of riot police could be
seen charging towards us from the south.
Jack Shenker records his experience of being beaten by police alongside protesters in Cairo Link to this audio
Along with nearby protesters I fled down the street before
stopping at what appeared to be a safe distance. A few ordinarily
dressed young men were running in my direction. Two came towards me and
threw out punches, sending me to the ground. I was hauled back up by the
scruff of the neck and dragged towards the advancing police lines.
My captors were burly and wore leather jackets up close I could see they were amin dowla, plainclothes officers from Egypt's
notorious state security service. All attempts I made to tell them in
Arabic and English that I was an international journalist were met with
more punches and slaps; around me I could make out other isolated
protesters receiving the same brutal treatment and choking from the
teargas.
We were hustled towards a security office on the edge of
the square. As I approached the doorway of the building other
plainclothes security officers milling around took flying kicks and
punches at me, pushing me to the floor on several occasions only to drag
me back up and hit me again. I spotted a high-ranking uniformed
officer, and shouted at him that I was a British journalist. He
responded by walking over and punching me twice. "Fuck you and fuck
Britain," he yelled in Arabic.
One by one we were thrown through
the doorway, where a gauntlet of officers with sticks and clubs awaited
us. We queued up to run through the blows and into a dank, narrow
corridor where we were pushed up against the wall. Our mobiles and
wallets were removed. Officers stalked up and down, barking at us to
keep staring at the wall. Terrified of incurring more beatings, most of
my fellow detainees almost exclusively young men in their 20s and 30s,
some still clutching dishevelled Egyptian flags from the protest remained silent, though some muttered Qur'anic verses and others were shaking with sobs
.
We
were ordered to sit down. Later a senior officer began dragging people
to their feet again, sending them back out through the gauntlet and into
the night, where we were immediately jumped on by more police officers
this time with riot shields and shepherded into a waiting green truck
belonging to Egypt's central security forces. A policeman pushed my
head against the doorframe as I entered.
Inside dozens were
already crammed in and crouching in the darkness. Some had heard the
officers count us as we boarded; our number stood at 44, all packed into
a space barely any bigger than the back of a Transit van. A heavy metal
door swung shut behind us.
As the truck began to move, brief
flashes of orange streetlight streamed through the thick metal grates on
each side. With no windows, it was our only source of illumination.
Each glimmer revealed bruised and bloodied faces; sandwiched in so
tightly the temperature soared, and people fainted. Fragments of
conversation drifted through the truck.
"The police attacked us to
get us out of the square; they didn't care who you were, they just
attacked everybody," a lawyer standing next to me, Ahmed Mamdouh, said
breathlessly. "They hit our heads and hurt some people. There are some
people bleeding, we don't know where they're taking us. I want to send a
message to my wife; I'm not afraid but she will be so scared, this is
my first protest and she told me not to come here today."
Despite
the conditions the protesters held together; those who collapsed were
helped to their feet, messages of support were whispered and then yelled
from one end of our metallic jail to another, and the few mobiles that
had been hidden from police were passed around so that loved ones could
be called.
"As I was being dragged in, a police general said to
me: 'Do you think you can change the world? You can't! Do you think you
are a hero? You are not'," confided Mamdouh.
"What you see here
this brutality and torture this is why we were protesting today,"
added another voice close by in the gloom.
Speculation was rife
about where we were heading. The truck veered wildly round corners,
sending us flying to one side, and regularly came to an emergency stop,
throwing everyone forwards. "They treat us like we're not Egyptians,
like we are their enemy, just because we are fighting for jobs," said
Mamdouh. I asked him what it felt like to be considered an enemy by your
own government. "I feel like they are my enemies too," he replied.
At
several points the truck roared to a stop and the single door opened,
revealing armed policemen on the other side. They called out the name of
one of the protesters, "Nour", the son of Ayman Nour, a prominent
political dissident who challenged Hosni Mubarak for the presidency in
2005 and was thrown in jail for his troubles.
Nour became a cause
celebre among international politicians and pressure groups; since his
release from prison security forces have tried to avoid attacking him or
his family directly, conscious of the negative publicity that would
inevitably follow.
His son, a respected political activist in his
own right, had been caught in the police sweep and was in the back of
the truck with us now the policemen were demanding he come forward, as
they had orders for his release.
"No, I'm staying," said Nour
simply, over and over again and to applause from the rest of the
inmates. I made my way through the throng and asked him why he wasn't
taking the chance to get out. "Because either I leave with everyone else
or I stay with everyone else; it would be cowardice to do anything
else," he responded. "That's just the way I was raised."
After
several meandering circles which seemed to take us out further and
further into the desert fringes of the city, the truck finally came to a
halt. We had been trapped inside for so long that the heat was
unbearable; more people had fainted, and one man had collapsed on the
floor, struggling for breath.
By the light of the few mobile
phones, protesters tore his shirt open and tried to steady his
breathing; one demonstrator had medical experience and warned that the
man was entering a diabetic coma. A huge cry went up in the truck as
protesters thumped the sides and bellowed through the grates: "Help, a
man is dying." There was no response.
After some time a commotion
could be heard outside; fighting appeared to be breaking out between
police and others, whom we couldn't make out.
At one point the
truck began to rock alarmingly from side to side while someone began
banging the metal exterior, sending out huge metallic clangs. We could
make out that a struggle was taking place over the opening of the door;
none of the protesters had any idea what lay on the other side, but all
resolved to charge at it when the door swung open. Eventually it did, to
reveal a police officer who began to grab inmates and haul them out,
beating them as they went. A cry went up and we surged forward, sending
the policeman flying; the diabetic man was then carried out carefully
before the rest of us spilled on to the streets.
Later it emerged
that we had won our freedom through the efforts of Nour's parents, Ayman
and his former wife Gamila Ismail. The father, who was also on the
demonstration, had got wind of his son's arrest and apparently followed
his captors and fought with officers for our release. Shorn of money and
phones and stranded several miles into the desert, the protesters began
a long trudge back towards Cairo, hailing down cars on the way.
The diabetic patient was swiftly put in a vehicle and taken to hospital; I have been unable to find out his condition.
How can we feed the world and still save the planet?
Underinvestment and
market failures have trapped many countries in a vicious cycle of low
productivity and exposure to price hikes, says Olivier de Schutter, the
UN special rapporteur on the right to food.
The UN special rapporteur on the right to food, Olivier De Schutter. Photograph: Alberto Pizzoli/AFP/Getty Images
Food
has become subject to one of the sharpest global debates, with rising
anxiety about how the world's growing population is going to feed
itself. Increasingly, Olivier de Schutter,
the UN special rapporteur on the right to food, is establishing himself
as one of its key protagonists with an unapologetically radical agenda.
In
London this week to give evidence to a UK parliamentary working group
on food and agriculture, he explained the challenge he is putting to the
donors and the international community.
Chronic underinvestment
in agriculture over the last 20 years combined with trade liberalisation
has trapped many developing countries in a vicious cycle of low
agricultural productivity and dependence on cheap food imports, he
argues. The one exacerbates the other as local farmers struggle, and
fail, to get a decent price for their produce in competition with
imports, which have often benefited from government subsidies.
Local farming goes into steep decline leading to migration to the cities. This is a serious market failure.
Faced
with large hungry (and often jobless) urban populations, government
policy is driven by the need to keep food cheap at all costs or risk
political instability, such as the rioting seen recently in countries such as Algeria.
"In
the short term, lower import tariffs to let in food ensure urban
populations are fed, but in the long term it is a disaster because local
farmers can't compete," says de Schutter, adding that cheap food
imports make the country extremely vulnerable to price hikes in the
global markets such as those we are now seeing.
"Since the early
1990s, the food bills of developing countries have increased by five-
or six-fold," says de Schutter. "This addiction to cheap food leads to
balance-of-payments problems and then political instability. It deprives
countries of their abilities to feed themselves."
This situation
has skewed the politics of countless countries where the priority has
been to maintain calm in urban areas while squeezing any value they can
from farmers. Farmers are marginalised politically and become
increasingly poor, further accelerating the migration to cities.
Donors
are finally recognising the need to invest in agriculture, but the
danger is that they put money into monoculture cash crops for export, a
strategy that that has no impact on improving food security for the poorest, argues de Schutter.
Another
major mistake being made by donors, he adds, is to offer inputs to
farmers such as subsidised fertiliser. This works in the short term but
is not sustainable in the longer term because the price of fertilisers
are linked to the rising price of oil, and the urgent task is to
decouple agriculture from oil.
The environmental challenge is
huge. "A third of all greenhouse emissions come from agriculture, so we
need to focus our efforts on an agriculture which does not degrade the
soil and which increases carbon capture," he explains, adding that he
will be presenting a paper on agroecology to the UN Human Rights Council in March.
He
wants donors to move away from the model of subsisidised fertilisers
and seeds which he calls "private goods", to supporting "public goods"
such as better infrastructure, strengthening local markets, ensuring
access to credit and building storage capabilities. Much of this needs
farmers to organise themselves to really bring benefits to rural areas.
"Farmers'
co-operatives emerged from the bottom-up in the 90s, and they now need
to move up the value chain into processing and packaging. Farmers can
get a better price if they organise together. And if they are organised,
then governments have to engage with them. Farmers need a greater voice
in the political process otherwise they don't get consulted and are
cheated," he says.
But he acknowledges that this is not always a
popular message. In many countries governments are wary of a strong,
well-organised farmers' co-operative movement that could threaten their
strategy to feed urban populations.
The challenge is huge because
in the last 25 years state agricultural extension services have been
dismantled, largely at the behest of structural adjustment programmes,
and farmers have been left to fend for themselves. To increase
productivity and introduce agroecology techniques in places such as sub
Saharan Africa requires institutions that can disseminate knowledge into
remote rural areas. This is no easy task.
Finally, de Schutter
has one other urgent recommendation. The G20 in May will be considering
measures to manage food-price volatility and he believes that food
reserves are an essential tool.
"My view is that food reserves
could be used to support the income of farmers, buying at a good price
and then make food affordable during times of rising prices. If a food
reserve is well managed and transparent, it could limit volatility and
secure incomes," he says.
He points out that China now has huge
food reserves in wheat, maize and rice that can shield the population
from price spikes. There are ongoing negotiations to arrange regional
collaboration across south-east Asia and to mutualise national food
reserves. Similar discussions took place last December in West Africa.
The G20 must put greater impetus behind such regional co-operation.
Sudan: stories from a country seared by war
The 22-year civil war
in southern Sudan left 2.5m people dead and millions more displaced. A
team from the US Holocaust Museum heard their harrowing stories ahead of
Sunday's independence referendum
Brisbane a 'ghost town' as residents flee floods - in pictures
People in the
Queensland state capital heed warnings and evacuate, leaving just a few
shopkeeeprs hoping to save their businesses with barricades of sandbags
and sheeting
Patients suffering from cholera in Haiti. Despite
calls from doctors for extra measures to prevent aid workers from
transferring the disease to local people, the disease is spreading
unchecked in the 'Republic of NGOs'. Photograph: Nicholas Kamm/AFP/Getty
Images
Despite breathless promises to "build back better", the
international community has made only incremental progress in Haiti over
the past 12 months. Our failures are especially stark when measured
against the genuine displays of global solidarity with Haiti in the wake
of the the January earthquake and financial pledges to reconstruction
three months later, in March.
Even if some allowance is made for
the extraordinary devastation wrought by the disasters, few disagree
that the Haitian government's handling of the situation has been
spectacularly poor. Likewise, with few exceptions, the international aid
sector's record has been dismal. Notwithstanding efforts to signal
political commitment to supporting Haiti's transition including UN secretary general Ban Ki Moon's appointment of Bill Clinton as special envoy
few tangible outcomes have yet to be materialise. Haitians themselves
are growing disillusioned and impatient, and signs of violence are
apparent in the streets of wrecked Port-au-Prince.
And while 2010 was grim, there are few guarantees that 2011 will be any better.
Veteran
disaster relief and development workers acknowledge that the process of
recovery and reconstruction takes time. But in Haiti, donors have been
especially slow in identifying priorities, disbursing funds and
supporting (rather than substituting for) local capacity. Although the
international community promised almost $10bn in aid earlier in 2010,
very little has actually arrived. What is more, support appears to be
dwindling. In 2010, more than 35 countries and multilateral agencies
pledged roughly $3.8bn to reconstruction. Going into 2011, pledges have
diminished to 20 countries amounting to $1.5bn.
The coordination
and commitment deficit is hardly new to Haiti. Even before the
earthquake, longstanding and newer donors were hoping to taper down
their security and development contributions. While the UN Stabilisation
Mission in Haiti's (Minustah) mandate has been repeatedly extended,
major troop and police contributing states (such as Brazil), as well as
aid providers such as Canada and the United States, were searching for
an exit strategy.
In the meantime, the Haitian Interim Recovery Commission
the government mechanism designed to coordinate and prioritise
international investment has failed to lift off. And while the
commission approved some $1.6bn in projects in August 2010, it is not
clear whether these initiatives can be sustained much beyond 2011.
Taken together, less than a tenth of the total amount promised has even arrived in Haiti, much less been spent.
Also
worrying is the way in which development aid agencies are resorting to
old practices, including preferential treatment of their own
contractors. On the grounds of minimising the risk of wasting aid
through corruption, "no bid" contracting is now the norm. This results
in serious distortions in aid allocations: out of every $100 pledged by
USAID, for example, Haitian firms are awarded less than $2. Other major
donors are following suit. This runs counter to the now widely-held view
among development professionals that supporting local capacity and
ingenuity is key to sustainable successful outcomes.
As most Haiti
watchers know all too well, the situation before the earthquake was
dire. Despite meagre economic gains in 2009, the country was at the very
bottom of virtually every international index. And while this "Republic
of NGOs" was visited by massive promises of assistance and an
additional 500 relief agencies in 2010, Haiti's three horsemen of the
apocalypse displacement, disease and instability have brought the
nation to its knees.
Almost 12 months after the earthquake, there
are still an estimated 1.3 million people living in tents, waiting to be
relocated to new houses. Recent household survey data revealed how, in
the months after the quake, these population groups were the most food
insecure. Less than a third of them claimed to have had access to
international assistance, and most managed to survive owing to resilient
social networks, including remittances from Montreal to Miami.
In the meantime, a cholera epidemic has killed over 2,500,
infected over 100,000 and could kill thousands more, if not immediately
contained. According to epidemiologists, the pathway of the epidemic
since October running as it has from north to the central and southern
regions suggests that it has spread virtually unhindered. Water
purification tablets, improved sanitation and small adaptations in
personal hygiene could effectively control its movement.
Finally, the country continues to be wracked by political instability.
The lack of leadership and poor handling of the elections have been
reported on extensively. Most of the 18 presidential candidates some
with links to the former regime of Duvalier dictators (father and son)
proved incapable of providing a compelling vision for Haiti's masses.
The persistent allegations of fraud and intimidation during the
electoral cycle were as predictable as they were depressing. The poor
way in which the vote count was managed and the weak response of
outsiders (notably, with the OAS and Minustah refusing to acknowledge
the full extent of "irregularities") guarantee continued unrest in 2011.
The
international community could not stop the earthquake, but surely it
can deliver on its promise to help Haitians reconstruct their battered
country
.
Last hurrah for the Harrier: Jump jets take to the skies for their final farewell
By Ian Drury Last updated at 12:52 PM on 16th December 2010
Flying in a spectacular
diamond formation so tight it ญappears they are ญalmost ญtouching, 16 of
Britains legendary jump jets soar through the wintry skies.
The occasion was billed as a celebration but, for many, the mood was as sombre as the gloomy weather.
On a freezing day heavy
with ญemotion, the ญHarrier the ญrevolutionary aircraft that helped
Britain defeat Argentina in the Falklands War in 1982 took to the air
for the last time.
Final salute: The 16-strong fleet of distinctive Harrier jump jets keep close formation in the skies above RAF Cottesmore today
Cutting edge: A Harrier takes off from the aircraft carrier Ark Royal. Both have become victims of Government defence cuts
Celebrations of Harrier 'VSTOL' (Vertical Short Take off and landing) Day at RAF Cottesmore
The sense of loss of
both the iconic fighter planes, and of a cherished piece of British
military and aviation history was symbolised in a moving tradition
called the walk of honour.
After landing the jets following their last flight, the pilots walked away from their craft without a single backward glance.
The Harrier jets have been
axed after falling victim to a savage round of defence cuts. Their next
stop, after being decommissioned next year, will be the scrapyard.
To mark their retirement
after 41 years ญservice, 16 Harriers were scheduled to take off from
their base at RAF Cottesmore, Rutland, and perform a spectacular flypast
of seven other RAF bases, the nearby towns of Stamford and Oakham, as
well as Lincoln Cathedral.
Unfortunately, the weather
spoiled the occasion. Conditions were so poor that the pilots, after
forming a ญdiamond formation, could not safely fly below the cloud
cover.
Nevertheless, more than
2,000 people turned out at the airfield to bid farewell, while the Red
Arrows performed a flypast in tribute.
Air Vice-Marshal Greg
Bagwell, the Air Officer Commanding No. 1 Group, said: The Harrier is a
true icon and stands testament to the innovation and excellence of
British design and engineering and the skill and courage of our airmen.
It has had a truly
distinguished service with the RAF and the Royal Navy, from the South
Atlantic to the skies over Afghanistan. It takes its place in history as
one of ญaviations greats.
Group Captain Gary
Waterfall, the Joint ญHarrier Force commander, said: This is an
emotional day for all those who have been fortunate to be involved with
one of the true icons of aviation, alongside Concorde and Spitfire.
Considered one of the
countrys greatest technological achievements, the British-built
military jets were the first in the world to be able to take off and
land vertically.
Introduced by the RAF in
1969, they were famed for their ability to hover above the ground, a
distinctive ญfeature which enabled them to fly in and out of areas close
to a battlefield that conventional aircraft could not reach.
The last hurrah: Harriers take off from RAF Cottesmore for a series of nostalgic fly-pasts before being decommissioned
An RAF Harrier puts on a
display at RAF Cottesmore, after a flypast passing over seven military
bases, the town centres of Stamford and Oakham and Lincoln Cathedral
before landing back at RAF Cottesmore
End of an era: Flypast to mark the retirement of the Harrier aircraft above RAF Cottesmore, Oakham
What they do best: Two Harriers hover just 40 feet off the ground at RAF Cottesmore yesterday
The 700mph Harriers played
a crucial role in defending the nations interests, seeing action in
every conflict from the Falklands where they were known as the Black
Death by Argentine pilots, after shooting down 25 enemy aircraft
without a single combat loss to the two Gulf Wars and five years in
Afghanistan.
The aircraft also flew combat ญmissions in Bosnia, Kosovo and Sierra Leone, providing close air support to troops on the ground.
But the 79-strong Harrier
fleet was axed in the coalition Governments strategic defence and
security review, saving less than ฃ1 billion. The decision sparked
controversy, because scrapping the 130 RAF Tornados which were
retained would have saved ฃ7.4billion.
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has written to David Cameron and security chiefs threatening legal action unless the wording is amended to comply with the UK's obligations.
It
also called for a forthcoming inquiry into allegations of British
complicity in torture of terror suspects to be held in public wherever
possible and its findings to be made public.
The Prime Minister announced the inquiry on July 6 after claims that former Guantanamo Bay detainee Binyam Mohamed was tortured with the knowledge of the British security services while held by the CIA in Pakistan.
A
number of other former detainees have since brought legal action
against the UK Government, claiming they were subjected to similar
mistreatment with the knowledge of MI5 or MI6.
Allegations have
also been made of UK involvement in the extra-judicial transfer, or
rendition, of terror suspects between countries since the 9/11 attacks
on the US.
The guidance was drawn up in the wake of the
complaints and published alongside the inquiry announcement. However,
EHRC legal director John Wadham wrote to Mr Cameron and senior cabinet
ministers expressing "serious concerns about the lawfulness of the
guidance...and to request its amendment".
In separate letters to
the heads of MI5 and MI6, Commission chairman Trevor Phillips said the
advice was "unhelpful" to officers on the ground and could unwittingly
leave them "personally liable for aiding and abetting torture".
The
watchdog warned Mr Cameron that it intended to exercise its legal right
to issue judicial review proceedings "if no satisfactory response" was
received by a deadline of 5pm this Thursday, September 30.
The Government's independent reviewer of terrorism
legislation, Lord Carlile, criticised the commission for proposing to
use taxpayers' money on a court case: "What I'm concerned about is the
use of taxpayers' money by the EHRC to sue the Government. I would have
thought that the EHRC could use taxpayers' money more beneficially by
putting in a submission to Sir Peter Gibson."
Four million Americans fall into poverty in one year
US Census Bureau shows one in seven Americans on poverty line as Obama says reforms are vital
Barack Obama said the US census figures showed that his reforms are vital. Photograph: Brian Kersey/Getty Images
One in seven Americans now live on or below the poverty line,
according to figures published by the US Census Bureau. It is the
sharpest annual rise for three decades, and analysts predicted next
year's figures will be even worse.
According to the bureau, 43.6 million people or 14.3% of the
population were in poverty in 2009, up from 39.8 million in 2008. This
is the third consecutive annual rise. The hardest-hit are
African-Americans and Hispanics.
The numbers are comparable to poverty levels of the early 1960s
that led President Lyndon Johnson to launch his "war on poverty" as
part of the "Great Society", a series of programmes aimed at creating
jobs and providing welfare his equivalent of Franklin D Roosevelt's
New Deal.
The jump coincided with the first year of Barack Obama's presidency and reflected the impact of the recession on jobs.
William Frey, a demographer at the Brookings Institution, said:
"The one-year gain in poverty is the highest in almost three decades,
when unemployment shot up in the early 1980s. It's only the beginning,
since I would expect an even higher level next year.
"What's important this time, is that [it] has especially affected
previously growing parts of the country in the south and west, and the
nation's fastest growing minorities, Hispanics. They are certainly not
as horrific as before the Great Society but they reflect a huge shock
to large parts of America."
The idea of the American Dream maintains a strong grip on the
imagination of many Americans and would-be citizens, but a detailed
breakdown of the figures reveals a grim reality.
CNN broadcast a harrowing interview with one woman who has fallen
into poverty. She lost her job, sold her television and furniture, even
her wedding rings, and depends on charitable food handouts. Named Maria
by CNN, she said she never expected to find her family in this
position. She had been an accountant and her husband worked for an
airline: both lost their jobs. They did temping jobs whenever they
could. They have two children, one of them autistic. "You either
gather yourself and look for options," she said. "Or you get depressed
and shoot yourself."
Many of those classified as poor have cable and satellite
television, fridges, air-conditioning units, microwaves and a roof over
their heads, even if it is just a caravan in a trailer park. But they
have little disposable income and few opportunities to step up the
ladder.
Obama promised during the presidential election to tackle poverty,
and to try to reduce the disparities between African-Americans and
white Americans, mainly through education.
Although the figures are embarrassing for him, they are unlikely
to become a major issue in the run-up to the 2 November congressional
midterm elections. The Republicans, while making jobs and the recession
election themes, will almost certainly not make poverty an issue,
partly because poverty rose under George Bush's presidency too.
Obama said the figures underlined why his reforms were vital.
"Today, the Census Bureau released data that illustrates just how tough
2009 was," he said. Without his reforms millions more Americans would
have ended up in poverty, he added.
Even before the recession, incomes for working-class people had
been stagnant and the numbers in poverty unacceptably high. "Today's
numbers make it clear that our work is just beginning. Our task now is
to continue working together to improve our schools, build the skills
of our workers, and invest in our nation's critical infrastructure,"
Obama said.
One of the alarming statistics in the Census Bureau report showed
the number without health insurance rose from 46.3 million in 2008 to
50.7 million in 2009. Obama introduced a healthcare reform package
earlier this year but most of the provisions are not due to kick in
until 2014.
Lyndon Johnson saw poverty at first-hand growing up in rural Texas
and as a teacher in a deprived school for Hispanics. During the
Depression, he played a part in implementing Roosevelt's New Deal. As
president, he launched a New Deal of his own the Great Society
which aimed to tackle poverty and racial discrimination.
Appalling levels of poverty still existed in the 1950s. In 1959,
the numbers on or below the poverty line was 22.4%. Even though, it had
dropped to 19% by 1964, when he made a State of the Union address
setting out his hopes for the Great Society, it was still
embarrassingly high for a country as wealthy as the US.
He introduced legislation in 1964 and 1965 that led to spending on
education, health, welfare and job programmes on a scale that has not
been repeated since.
Ewen MacAskill
Fire Devil Twister Blazes A Trail In Brazil
(c) Sky News 2010
A
fire tornado caused by bush fires and strong winds has stopped motorway
traffic as drivers in Brazil gawped at the rare phenomenon.
The whirlwind of flames burned through fields beside the road in the northwest city of Aracatuba in Sao Paulo state.
But, as quickly as it appeared, the roaring twister fizzled down and just a smouldering line in the land remained.
The firestorm followed a drought which has led to brush fires across Brazil.
It has been three months since it last rained in the region and Sao Paulo state is already suffering from high pollution levels.
Humidity levels have also soared with Globo TV reporting they were similar to those in the Sahara desert.
As a precaution, state authorities have forbidden farmers from burning sugar cane field waste, a typical after-harvest activity.
In the most remote areas municipalities with few resources have been unable to contain fires.
Fire
tornados, also known as fire whirls or fire devils, are rare and depend
on certain air temperatures and currents to create a vertical, rotating
column of air.
In 1923, a fire tornado ignited by the Great Kanto
earthquake in Tokyo grew to the size of a large city and killed 38,000
people in 15 minutes.
At the time most of the buildings in Japan were made from wood and fire spread from house to house, destroying the city.
It estimated the earthquake and the ensuing fire killed between 100,000 and 141,000 people
To remember those who died in the landslide in Gansu Province one
week ago, Chinese people held mourning ceremonies across the country on
Sunday. Chinese national flags throughout the nation are flying at half
mast.
Before dawn on Sunday morning, at Potala Square in the Tibet
Autonomous Region, the Chinese flag was lowered to half mast. Standing
silently in front of the flag, people in the square remembered the
victims.
The national flag of China is seen at half mast at the Potala Palace Square in Lhasa, capital of southwest China's Tibet Autonomous Region, Aug. 15, 2010, to mourn for the victims of the Aug. 8 mudslide disaster in Zhouqu County, Gannan Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture in northwest China's Gansu Province. China on Sunday held mournings for the mudslide victims, all over the country and at overseas embassies and consulates. (Xinhua/Chogo)
Local Resident, Tibet Autonomous region, said, "We hope people in
the disaster areas rebuild their families soon. Come on Zhouqu!"
In the city of Dalian, at People's Square, the national flag at
half mast represents the grief of the people of Dalian. But it also
symbolizes hope for a better future.
UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon meets young flood victims at a relief
camp in Muzaffargarh district of Punjab province, Pakistan. Photograph: STR/Pakistan/Reuters
The UN secretary general, Ban Ki-moon, has urged the world to speed up aid efforts to Pakistan as the country braces itself for further flooding with the waters of the swollen Indus river reaching critical levels.
"This has been a heart-wrenching day for me," Ban said after
flying over some of the worst-hit areas. "I will never forget the
destruction and suffering I have witnessed today. In the past I have
witnessed many natural disasters around the world, but nothing like
this."
The UN has appealed for an initial ฃ295m to provide relief, but
only 20% of that has so far been given. "Waves of flood must be met
with waves of support from the world," said Ban. "I'm here to urge the
world to step up assistance," he said.
Ban has met the prime minister, Yousuf Raza Gilani, and the president, Asif Ali Zardari, who was fiercely condemned for failing to cut short a European visit as the crisis deepened.
In his first comments to the media since returning, Zardari
defended the government's response. "The government has responded very
responsibly," he said, saying the army, the police and officials were
all working to relieve the suffering. "I would appeal to the press to
understand the magnitude of the disaster."
With more than 1,600 people confirmed dead and as many as 20 million
made homeless, the country is reeling from the scale of the catastrophe
brought by torrential monsoon rains.
Gilani said Pakistan now faced challenges similar to those during
the 1947 partition of the subcontinent, when as many as 500,000 people
were killed.
His warning came amid growing fears of social unrest or even a military
takeover after the government's shambolic response. "The nation faced
the situation successfully at that time of the partition and, God
willing, we will emerge successful in this test," he said.
In the southern province of Sindh, 1.6 million people are stranded
and half a million have been ordered to abandon their homes. The first
case of cholera since the disaster began has been recorded in the
northern Swat valley, while survivors across the eastern state of
Punjab are sleeping in the open without shelter.
The situation in some areas is threatening to spill over into
violence, according to witnesses. An Associated Press correspondent in
Sindh reported seeing survivors fighting over food, ripping at each
other's clothes and causing such chaos that the distribution had to be
abandoned. "The impatience of the people has deprived us of the little
food that had come," Shaukat Ali, a flood victim waiting for aid, said.
Although water levels are continuing to rise, offers of
international aid remain small compared with recent disasters
elsewhere, to the dismay of Pakistan's leaders and aid agencies. Only
ฃ96m has been pledged with ฃ31m of that from the British government
in response to the UN appeal.
International donations in the wake of the Haiti earthquake
earlier in the year totalled ฃ1.5bn. David Cameron's criticism of
Pakistan as an exporter of terrorism has been blamed in part for the
lack of public sympathy, as has Zardari's failure to cancel his visit
to Britain.
India yesterday pledged ฃ3.2m, the same amount it gave to Haiti,
but not before its apparent hesitancy prompted claims that a recent
political spat was overriding its humanitarian imperative. Critics said
Pakistan did not hesitate to come to India's aid when the Gujarat
earthquake killed 25,000 people in 2001. They said that India's offer
was a tiny fraction of its ฃ500m aid budget for this year.
China, which initially offered just ฃ960,000, has now increased
its contribution to ฃ4.6m. Britain's Disasters Emergency Committee
appeal has raised ฃ12m from public donations.
Zamir Akram, Pakistan's ambassador to the UN, criticised the
international response and claimed that the scale of the disaster was
only just beginning to become apparent.
Late yesterday, there were no indications that the worst was over.
Pakistan's flood control department warned that water in the upper
reaches of the Indus was at "very high levels".
At some points along its course, the river was reported to be 15
miles wide, more than 25 times its normal size. Further flooding is now
expected in Sindh province, which includes Karachi, the country's
largest city.
The discovery of the first cholera case in Mingora, in the Swat
valley, confirmed the fears of aid agencies who had been warning of the
danger of disease. Cholera can lead to severe dehydration and death
without prompt treatment, and containing cholera outbreaks is a
priority following floods.
The UN said it feared the case was not isolated, adding that it
was now treating 36,000 people as if they were suffering from cholera.
Aid agencies warned that 6 million children were at risk of
life-threatening diarrhoeal diseases, malnutrition and pneumonia.
A 28-year-old Save the Children worker, unnamed for security
reasons, undertook a 30-mile trek to assist aid distribution programmes
in the town of Kalam, in the Swat valley, after roads in the area were
destroyed.
On his blog, he wrote: "We reached the first town, Adyan, after
crossing two hills. The entire shape of the city had changed ‑ the
floods created a river that went straight through the middle of town,
completely destroying the main market. "Mud and dust was everywhere,
as were huge boulders that the flood had carried right into town. We
finally reached a city, Bahrain, which used to be a big tourist
destination with lots of hotels, restaurants, and beautiful riverside
cafes. I was there five years ago on holiday with my family.
"The city is now unrecognisable. It is like something has taken a
huge pile of rocks and mud and thrown it all over the city. The main
bazaar is completely destroyed. Three-storey hotels have tumbled down
and the main road through the town was covered in five feet of mud.
"In Kalam, 90% of the main market, which provides a livelihood for
so many people, was completely destroyed. It looked like it might have
100 years ago: no cars ‑ they had all washed away ‑ no clean water
supply, which was previously run by an electric pumping station, now
destroyed."
Fears Russian wildfires could send Chernobyl waste to Moscow
Ecologist
says radioactive particles from trees and plants burnt by summer fires
in the Chernobyl fall-out area could be carried on the wind for
hundreds of miles.
A firefighter works to extinguish a wildfire outside the settlement of
Kustarevka in Ryazan region, 211 miles south-east of Moscow.
Photograph: Denis Sinyakov/Reuters
Forest wardens stepped up patrols in the Chernobyl fallout zone
today as a leading ecologist warned that fires there could send
radioactive particles as far as Moscow. About 160,000 emergency personnel are battling 600 wildfires across Russia, 290 of which ignited in the last 24 hours.
Greenpeace said that at least 20 fires, three of them in a highly
contaminated forest area, had broken out in recent days in Bryansk
region, bordering northern Ukraine. Bryansk was part of the zone
sprayed with a plume of radioactive isotopes caesium-137 and
strontium-90 when the Chernobyl power plant's fourth reactor exploded
in 1986.
Alexei Yablokov, an ecologist and member of the Academy of
Sciences, warned that winds could spread contaminants embedded in trees
and plants as they succumb to the inferno.
"Radionuclides may reach places at distances of hundreds of
kilometres, depending on the weather," he said. "If the Bryansk region
is in flames, they can reach the Novgorod region, Moscow, and in some
conditions, eastern Europe."
There were conflicting reports over the extent of the fires in
Bryansk. Asked about the gravity of the threat, Gennady Onishchenko,
the country's top public health official, said: "There's no need to sow
panic. Everything is quiet there."
But Russia's forestry protection service said it was increasing
patrols in the area after about 30 hectares of land went up in flames.
"The situation is complicated, but stable and controllable," an
official from the service told Interfax.
Greenpeace played down fears of Chernobyl pollution reaching
Moscow, but said the harmful potential of smaller doses of radiation
combined with smog, carbon monoxide and other particles should not be
overlooked.
A veil of acrid smog lifted from Moscow on Tuesday morning but
temperatures remained in the 30s Celcius (86+F) as political
repercussions of the wildfires crisis emerged.There was growing evidence that the absence of the city's powerful mayor during its hour of need could hasten his demise.
Yury Luzhkov left for holidays and "treatment for a serious sports
injury" as the city sweltered on 2 August and did not return until
Sunday, several days after a toxic cloud enveloped the city. A senior
health official has said the smog killed at least 320 more people each
day than usually die in the city.
Luzhkov, in office since 1992, is the last of the regional
heavyweights in Russian politics, but his future as city boss has
looked increasingly fragile amid allegations of sleaze and incompetence.
Prime minister Vladimir Putin
greeted the tanned-looking mayor in a televised meeting yesterday,
saying: "You were quite right to return from your vacation. Your timing
is perfect."
Observers interpreted those comments as an acid hint that Putin
disapproved of Luzhkov's late showing. "Luzhkov underestimated the
political situation and he underestimated how serious and tense the
situation in Moscow is," said Gleb Pavlovsky, a political analyst with
close ties to the Kremlin. "Surely, he is in a very weak position now and worsened it even
more by saying, amid all that is happening, that the situation in
Moscow is quite normal."
Before Luzhkov returned, his spokesman, Sergei Tsoi, had claimed
there was little reason for the mayor to cut short his break because
there was no emergency. The fires causing Moscow's smog were outside
the capital, Tsoi said, and therefore "nothing depends on the city
authorities in dealing with the current environmental situation".
Luzhkov, 73, denied rumours that he was getting treatment in Tyrol, Austria, but declined to say where he had been.
Deputy mayor Vladimir Resin made a clumsy attempt to exonerate his
boss, saying he had a backlog of 370 days of holiday. "He could have
taken a whole year off," he said.
But a Kremlin source said it was "too bad" Luzhkov hadn't returned
from holiday sooner. "The mayor's absence obviously did not help the
necessary decisions to have been made in timely fashion," he said
Endgame in Afghanistan: 'It's taken a year to move 20km'
As
the war in Afghanistan enters its final chapter, Sean Smith's brutal,
uncompromising film from the Helmand frontline shows the horrific chaos
of a stalemate that is taking its toll in blood
Guardian film-maker and photographer Sean Smith
has just spent five weeks in Afghanistan, first with a US helicopter
ambulance crew, and then with the US marines. This is his astonishing
diary of his time with special forces
Speaking on the White House lawn after a meeting with
Congressional leaders to discuss funding for the war and other issues,
the US president deplored the leak, saying he was concerned the
information from the battleground could jeopardise the lives of US
soldiers.
But he went on to say that the material, which catalogues a series
of blunders, revealed the challenges that led him to announce late last
year a change in strategy that involved sending an additional 30,000
troops to Afghanistan.
The tens of thousands of documents were sent to the website Wikileaks and published in the Guardian, the New York Times and Der Spiegel.
They deal mainly with the conduct of the war during the Bush
administration, which Obama has repeatedly accused of ignoring the
Afghanistan war because of its focus on Iraq.
"For seven years, we failed to implement a strategy for this
region," Obama said yesterday, of the period starting with the 9/11
attacks on New York and Washington.
"That is why we have increased our commitment there and developed
a new strategy," he said, adding that he had also sent one of the
finest generals in the US, General David Petraeus.
He ended with a plea to the House of Representatives to join the
Senate in passing a bill needed to provide funds for the Afghan war.
The leaks have put attention on Afghanistan at a time when the
Obama administration would rather focus on the economy, the main issue
among voters, and have put pressure on him to explain why he thinks his
new strategy will stand any better chance of success than the old one.
Obama is also facing pressure to explain continued financial,
military and other support for Pakistan, in spite of allegations in the
leaked documents that elements in the Pakistan intelligence service are
supporting the Taliban.
Members of Congress are becoming increasingly sceptical in public
about the conduct of the war, and public support is falling. According
to a Reuters/Ipsos poll
published today, satisfaction with Obama's handling of the war has
dropped to 33%, down from 38% in January and 47% in February last year.
Afghanistan war logs: tensions increase after revelation of more leaked files
Coalition commanders hid civilian deaths, war logs reveal US, Afghanistan and Pakistan trade angry accusations Leak poses 'very real threat' to US forces - White House
The Pentagon
said it was conducting an investigation into whether information in the
logs placed coalition forces or their informants in danger. Photograph: John Moore/Getty Images
Further disclosures reveal more evidence of attempts by coalition
commanders to cover up civilian casualties in the conflict. The
details emerge from more than 90,000 secret US military files, covering
six years of the war, which caused a worldwide uproar when they were
leaked yesterday.
Coalition commanders received numerous intelligence reports about the whereabouts and activity of Osama bin Laden between 2004 and 2009, even though the CIA chief has said there has been no precise information about the al-Qaida leader since 2003.
Four days after it was first approached by the Guardian, the
British Ministry of Defence said it was still unable to give an account
of two questionable clusters of civilian shootings by British troops
detailed in the American logs.
The UK foreign secretary, William Hague, told the BBC that the
leaked documents could "poison the atmosphere in Afghanistan" but at
the same time insisted they would not affect British troops:
Writing in the Guardian, Eric Joyce, a former soldier and
parliamentary aide to the former Labour defence secretary Bob
Ainsworth, described the leaked documents as a "game changer", adding that some of the questions raised were "stunning in their enormity".
The former Liberal Democrat leader and spokesman on defence and
foreign affairs, Sir Menzies Campbell, said the documents showed how
difficult it would be for UK troops to leave Afghanistan in 2015, the
date set by David Cameron. "The leaked documents show just how awesome
the task will be to bring the Afghan police and army to a condition
where they can be responsible for security," said Campbell.
Amnesty International called for reforms to the recording of
civilian casualties after a row broke out over an incident in which the
Afghan government says 45 villagers were killed in a rocket attack. The
coalition disputes that it was responsible. Amnesty called on Nato "to
provide a clear, unified system of accounting for civilian casualties
in Afghanistan".
Daniel Ellsberg compared the publication of the war logs to the Pentagon Papers,
which he leaked to the New York Times in 1971. "The Pentagon Papers did
not stop or even affect the war but affected public opinion a great
deal. Are we really going to do better with another $300bn [spent on
the war in Afghanistan] on more bombs, more special forces, more
drones? The Taliban are not going to quit."
The director of the military thinktank the Royal United Services
Institute, Professor Michael Clarke, said in London: "There is no doubt
that the leaks are politically pretty damaging. The papers give an
impression of a lack of military discrimination in how operations were
conducted."
The Pentagon said it was conducting an investigation into whether
information in the logs placed coalition forces or their informants in
danger.
Last night President Obama's press secretary, Robert Gibbs, claimed the logs published by the Wikileaks
website posed "a very real threat" to US forces: "It's not the content
there are names, there are operations, there are sources, all of that
information out in the public domain has the potential to do harm."
The Guardian was allowed to investigate the logs for several weeks ahead of publication, along with the New York Times and the German weekly Der Spiegel. The three have published excerpts from the documents which do not pose a risk to informants or military operations.
Aid and corruption in Afghanistan
It's not a lack of money that's the problem for Afghan people, it's how the aid they have already been given is spent, or stolen
If Afghanistan suffers from anything, it's certainly not a lack
of donor conferences. The country has clocked up on average one a year
since the fall of the Taliban, raising some $40bn dollars along the
way.
At each one, delegates announce that Afghanistan is at a critical
juncture, pledge it will not be forgotten by the international
community and vow that we are well on the way to full Afghan ownership.
A few billion dollars are usually donated too.
But Kabul on 20 July
is not going to be another pledging event, we are told. This time, it's
going to be different. This time, we are going to witness an Afghan-led
event, a national development road map presented to 70 international
actors and donors. The major issues are handing over responsibilities
from international to local forces, the fight against corruption and
talking to the Taliban.
So what progress can they present?
It's true that recruitment appears to be up for the Afghanistan
National Security Force (ANSF), a crucial part of Barack Obama's handover strategy,
which now consists of some 134,000 soldiers and about 90,000 policemen.
But figures are meaningless when these forces can't properly function. According to a US audit,
ANSF operational capabilities have been hugely overstated, with
inadequate training, systemic desertion, theft, drug abuse and
illiteracy. Attempts to boost security through recruiting local
militias to combat insurgents (an effort that seems copy-and-pasted out
of the Iraq strategy book) have proved highly controversial and
unpopular. Meanwhile, violence continues to rise. More than 1,000
civilians were killed in the first six months of this year, mostly by
insurgent forces. And last month alone, the Nato-led force in
Afghanistan suffered a record loss of 102 soldiers.
As for good governance, the only progress seems to be that the
international community is realising that aid without proper oversight
does not lead to stability in fact, quite the reverse. Last month, billions of dollars in US aid were blocked and this week a 200m EU package was delayed
until after the conference. Far from decreasing, corruption has doubled
in the last three years, and there are fears that the parliamentary
elections in September will be as flawed as last year's presidential polls.
When it comes to talking to the Taliban, the international community
is in as much disarray over this policy as Afghanistan itself. With
Nato keen, Washington opposed and Pakistan angling for its own very
friendly government in Kabul, there is no clear way forward. Opposition
within Hamid Karzai's own government led to the removal of interior minister Hanif Atmar and intelligence chief Amrullah Saleh last month. Ethnic groups are divided and no one trusts Kabul to negotiate on their behalf.
So is the Kabul conference going to achieve anything? It's
questionable whether big bells-and-whistles events ever do. As with the
Gaza conference in March last year,
at which $4.5bn (ฃ3.2bn) was pledged, the international community seems
to be missing the point. The residents of Gaza didn't need more money;
they needed access to services and freedom of movement and the ability
to rebuild their beleaguered territory.
Similarly, a few more billion dollars in aid or pledges of
support are not going to help solve the problems of Afghanistan. It's
not the lack of money; it's how the money they have already been given
is spent, or stolen. It's the refusal of the international community to
hold President Karzai to account. And it's the fact that more than
eight years after the fall of the Taliban, the coalition forces have
failed to actually decide what they want to achieve in Afghanistan
military victory, nation-building, defence of strategic interests or
agree on a coherent strategy to accomplish it.
International aid under threat
Foreign aid diverted to stabilise Afghanistan
International development
secretary, Andrew Mitchell, will announce plans to boost aid funding to
Afghanistan by 40%, while the likes of Russia and China will lose out
Andrew Mitchell MP, secretary for international development. Photograph: Allstar/Dave Gadd
Britain is to cut aid worth hundreds of millions of pounds to
countries around the world to help pay for projects aimed at speeding
the withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan, the Observer can reveal.
Detailed plans to boost aid funding to Afghanistan by 40% as
part of a re-ordering of global priorities will be outlined tomorrow by
the international development secretary, Andrew Mitchell.
The news emerged on another bloody day of conflict as four
British servicemen were killed in separate incidents in Afghanistan in
24 hours, bringing the military death toll in the country to 322 since
2001.
Mitchell will cite Afghanistan as the main beneficiary of a
review of aid to around 90 countries that benefit from the Department
for International Development's ฃ2.9bn aid budget.
Countries already expected to experience cuts in UK aid include
long-term beneficiaries turned economic powerhouses such as Russia and
China. It is understood that the review will also look at cutting or
ending aid to a number of countries in South America and eastern
Europe. Sources said money would continue to be channelled as a matter
of priority to the poorest countries, many in Africa.
But the search for other cuts will range far more widely.
Overall, the number of countries receiving UK bilateral aid is likely
to be more than halved to well under 50.
Mitchell, whose DfID budget has been "ringfenced" from the
government's austerity drive, is under intense pressure from sections
of his own party to justify its special status while other departments,
including the Home Office and Department for Work and Pensions, face
cuts of 25% to 40%.
The coalition government has also promised to meet the legally
binding target, set by Labour, of providing an aid budget of 0.7% of
national output, which will mean real-terms increases. This has placed
DfID under an even greater obligation to deliver value.
Mitchell will stress that an aid expansion to Afghanistan from
ฃ500m to ฃ700m over the next four years will help the country stand on
its own feet improving stability, the economy and government, and
allowing UK troops to come home within David Cameron's target of five
years.
That target appeared a long way off yesterday when an airman
for the RAF Regiment died in a road accident near Camp Bastion in
Helmand, a marine from 40 Commando Royal Marines died in an explosion
in Sangin, and a member of the Royal Dragoon Guards died in a blast in
the Nahr-e Saraj district of Helmand. A soldier from the Royal
Logistics Corps was last night also killed in another blast in Nahr-e
Saraj. Next of kin have been informed.
The Royal Logistics Corps soldier was part of a bomb disposal
team clearing a route in southern Nahr-e Saraj so that local people
could move more freely, according to a spokesman for the Army's Task
Force Helmand, Lieutenant Colonel James Carr-Smith. "He was a very
brave and courageous man and he will be missed by us all," he added.
The soldier from the Royal Dragoons, whose death was announced
earlier in the day, was part of a patrol providing security to enable
new roads and security bases to be constructed north-east of Gereshk.
The two other deaths of the marine killed in an explosion
while on patrol with US marines, supported by the Afghan army, in
Sangin, and the airman who died in a road accident north of Camp
Bastion, the main British military base occurred on Friday. The
latest fatalities come as a massive hunt continues for a rogue Afghan
soldier who killed three UK troops.
"Using the UK's aid budget to secure progress in Afghanistan will be my number one priority," Mitchell will say tomorrow.
The new emphasis at DfID would appear to be at odds with recent
comments by the defence secretary, Liam Fox, who said: "We are not in
Afghanistan for the sake of the education policy in a broken,
13th-century country. We are there so the people of Britain and our
global interests are not threatened."
Mitchell's approach will please many in his own party who
dislike the ringfencing of the aid budget, but is proving controversial
with some aid agencies, which do not want the aid budget to be used for
what they see as military-related goals.
"Aid should be about helping the most needy, but it's not any more," one charity head told the Observer.
"It's about backing up the country's political leaders, and I don't
think taxpayers expect money taken to help the world's poor to be
propping up the government's military affairs."
Mitchell will insist, however, that by pumping in more aid to
Afghanistan the goals of stability and a UK withdrawal can be achieved
more quickly. "I am determined to back up the efforts of our armed
forces as we work towards a withdrawal of combat troops," he will say.
"Nowhere is the case clearer of why well-spent aid overseas is in our
national interest than in Afghanistan. The UK is there to prevent the
Afghan territory from again being used by al-Qaida as a base from which
to plan attacks on the UK and our allies. While the military bring
much-needed security, peace will only be achieved through political
progress backed by development."
Alongside an increase in the size and pace of UK aid efforts,
Mitchell will set out steps to ensure the UK's work in Afghanistan is
more effective. President Hamid Karzai will announce a timetable for a
"conditions-based and phased transition" at the international
conference on Afghanistan to be held in Kabul on Tuesday. British
troops are to pull out by 2014, according to a leaked communiqu้
obtained by the Independent on Sunday.
World media's reaction to Hu Jintao's speech at G20
Chinese President Hu Jintao's speech at the G20 summit in Toronto
has drawn world attention. Different comments emerged in different
papers soon after the summit concluded.
The Xinhua News Agency talked to Alan Alexandroff, the co-director
of the G20 Research Group. He says that a report shows China's efforts
to make the G20 an efficient organization. He says that President Hu's
speech also unveils China's support to the other developing nations,
which is very valuable. Hu Jintao's speech highlighted the problems in
China. Alexandroff says the comments are objective, which proves that
China faces challenges if it tries to maintain its economic growth.
China Daily quoted economists as saying that the reform of China's
currency exchange system is not only in the interests of its own
economy, but will also help ease the imbalance of international trade
and economy. But they also warned those developed countries who have
attempted to blame China for the imbalance in the world's economy not
to expect too much on China's currency exchange reform.
France's paper Le Monde says the G20 enables China to promote its
world status, and even play a major role, as the G20 is formed purely
out of economic factors.
World comments on Hu's speech
Alan Alexandroff, co-director of G20 Research Group
China's efforts to make G20 more efficient.
It's valuable that China is supportive to other developing nations.
China still faces challenges in economic development.
Foreign economists:
Reform of China's currency exchange system is beneficial to the world's economy.
Developed countries should not expect a high appreciation of the RMB.
G20 ---a good chance for China to promote its status.
Expo 2010 opening ceremony: spectacular fireworks display in China
Shanghai celebrated the opening of the 2010 World Expo with a
lavish riverside display of fireworks, fountains and lasers that
rivalled the launch of the Beijing Olympics in its extravagance
River on the roof of the world ... the Yarlung Tsangpo/Brahmaputra river. Photograph: Imaginechina
Chinese hydropower lobbyists are calling for construction of the
world's biggest hydro-electric project on the upper reaches of the
Brahmaputra river as part of a huge expansion of renewable power in the
Himalayas.
Zhang Boting, the deputy general secretary of the China
Society for Hydropower Engineering, told the Guardian that a massive
dam on the great bend of the Yarlung Tsangpo - the Tibetan name for the
river - would benefit the world, despite the likely concerns of
downstream nations, India and Bangladesh, which access water and power from the
river.
Zhang said research had been carried out on the project, but no
plan has been drawn up. But documents on the website of a government
agency suggest a 38 gigawatt hydropower plant is under consideration
that would be more than half as big again as the Three Gorges dam, with
a capacity nearly half as large as the UK's national grid.
"This dam could save 200m tonnes of carbon each year. We should
not waste the opportunity of the biggest carbon emission reduction
project. For the sake of the entire world, all the water resources than
can be developed should be developed." That CO2 saving would be over a
third of the UK's entire emissions.
The mega-facility is among more than 28 dams on the river that are
either planned, completed or under discussion by China, according to
Tashi Tsering, a Tibetan scholar of environmental policy at the
University of British Columbia.
Tsering publishes a map today of all of the projects that have been reported by Chinese newspapers and hydro-engineering websites.
From this, he concludes that the Tsangpo-Brahmaputra until recently considered the last great undammed river in Tibet will be the next focus of government efforts to increase the nation's power supply. One of them is a map of planned dams
showing a 38-gigawatt hydro-plant at Motuo on the website of Hydro
China, an influential government enterprise responsible for dam
construction. A separate State Grid map of future transmission lines
indicates the remote area will soon be connected to the rest of China's
power supply. Hydro China and State Grid declined requests for
clarification.
The government has not confirmed the existence of the scheme, but
Tsering cites several newspaper reports of survey teams exploring the
area and provides links to other online documents that indicate
preparations for large-scale hydro-development of the area.
Given the huge expense, technical difficulties and political
sensitivities of the scheme, it is far from certain of final approval
by the government. But several Chinese hydroengineers see it as the
ultimate goal in an accelerating race with India to develop water
resources in one of the planet's last remote regions.
Tapping the power of the river as it bends and plunges from the
Himalayan roof of the world down towards the Indian and Bangladeshi
flood plains has long been a dream of the world's hydro-engineers.
Along with the Congo river at the Inga falls, this is considered one of the two greatest concentrations of river energy
on earth, but it was long thought impossible to access because of the
rugged, high-altitude terrain and the risk of water-related conflict
with neighbouring countries.
But China has overcome many engineering obstacles with the
construction of the railway to Tibet, and its growing energy demands
are spurring exploration of ever more remote areas.
"Tibet's resources will be converted into economic advantage," Yan
Zhiyong, the general manager of China Hydropower Engineering Consulting
Group, told China Energy News earlier this year. "The major technical
constraints on damming the Yarlung Tsampo have been overcome." He
declined the Guardian's request for an interview, saying the subject
was too sensitive.
The exploitation of the Brahmaputra is already under way. China
recently announced plans to build five dams further upstream, including
a 500MW hydroplant at Zangmu, which is under construction by the power
utility Huaneng.
According to Tsering, the biggest of them will be a huge plant at
the great bend either at Metog, known as Motuo in Chinese, or at
Daduqia. The former would involve the construction of a series of
tunnels, pipes, reservoirs and turbines to exploit the spectacular
2,000-metre fall of the river as it curls down towards India.
Although there has been no official confirmation of plans for a dam, the discussion is far from secret. On a prominent Chinese science forum,
Zhang said a dam on the great bend was the ultimate hope for water
resource exploitation because it could generate energy equivalent to
100m tonnes of crude coal, or all the oil and gas in the South China
sea.
He warned that a delay would allow India to tap these resources
and prompt "major conflict" in a region where the two nations have
sporadically clashed over disputed territory.
"We should build a hydropower plant in Motuo ... as soon as
possible because it is a great policy to protect our territory from
Indian invasion and to increase China's capacity for carbon reduction,"
he wrote last year
Any step forward is likely to be controversial. Tibetans consider
Metog a sacred region, and environmental activists warn against
building such a huge project in a seismically active and ecologically
fragile area.
"A large dam on the Tibetan plateau would amount to a major,
irreversible experiment with geo-engineering," said Peter Bosshard of
International Rivers. "Blocking the Yarlung Tsangpo could devastate the
fragile ecosystem of the Tibetan plateau, and would withhold the
river's sediments from the fertile floodplains of Assam in north-east
India, and Bangladesh."
China's construction of dams also raises the prospect of a race
with India to develop hydropower along south Asia's most important
river.
"India needs to be more aggressive in pushing ahead hydro projects
(on the Brahmaputra)," Jairam Ramesh, the Indian environment minister,
told the Guardian during a recent visit to Beijing. "That would put us in better negotiating position (with China).
To minimise the risk of water-related conflict, the two nations
have agreed to share information about hydro-plans on the
Tsangpo-Brahmaputra.
Indian media have raised concerns that Beijing may ultimately
embark on a gigantic diversion scheme that would channel water away
from India to the dry northern plains of China, but such fears are
dismissed by Tsering, who says the dam at Metog would be for
hydropower, not water diversion. "The laws of physics will not allow
water diversion from the Great Bend."
Honduras - Cocaine trade turns backwater into hideout for brutal assassins
The Central American nation is on the brink of becoming a fully-fledged narco-state
Major
Leslie Portillo grieves over the murdered body of her husband,
Honduras' top anti-drug official Julian Aristides Gonzales. Photograph:
Esteban Felix/AP
The term "banana republic"
implies an element of comedy or the absurd, but there is nothing funny
about the murders and lawlessness sweeping Honduras.
The
central American country, once a sleepy backwater known mainly for
fruit exports, has become a haven for narco-traffickers and assassins.
In recent weeks union leaders, political activists and priests have all
been targeted.
Corrupt police and drugs gangs are blamed, with
the government unable or unwilling to crack down on them. Before being
shot dead in broad daylight last December his grieving wife is
pictured over his body, above Julian Aristides, head of the drug
control office, warned that Honduras risked becoming a narco-state.
The
mayhem is a grisly sequel to what started as an almost picaresque tale
last June when soldiers seized President Manuel Zelaya in his pyjamas
and exiled him. The coup was universally condemned but initially
bloodless. Zelaya's efforts to slip back into Honduras, culminating in
his taking refuge in the Brazilian embassy and an occasionally farcical
military siege, could have been penned by Graham Greene.
The saga
supposedly ended in January when a newly elected president, Porfirio
Lobo, took office and Zelaya, his term expired, voluntarily went back
into exile. But since then the traditional ruling class which toppled
Zelaya with limited protest from the US has been paralysed by
escalating violence centred in the north of the country. Critics say
state elements are in the pay of gangs that take Colombian cocaine from
Venezuela to Honduras, then to Mexico and the US.
Journalists
have been gunned down almost every week. Text messages to Gerardo
Chevez, a reporter for Radio Progreso, say he will be next. Political
activists, especially Zelaya supporters, have been abducted, abused and
killed. A Jesuit priest, Ismael Moreno, received death threats after
sheltering a woman who said she was raped by police.
With trust in state institutions low, potential victims hope international attention will afford some protection.
Everest's death zone
Sherpa expedition plans to climb some 8,000 metres to remove bodies of dead mountaineers and clear tonnes of rubbish
Mount
Everest's South Col had become known as the world's highest rubbish
tip, with snow the littered with discarded climbing equipment. Photograph: AP
A team of Nepali mountaineers will leave Kathmandu tomorrow heading for Mount Everest,
the world's highest peak, where they hope to climb to more than 8,000
metres (26, 246ft) to clear the mountain's "death zone" of tonnes of
rubbish and remove the bodies of dead climbers.
Though many foreign and Nepali expeditions have set out to clear
parts of the mountain in the past, Namgyal Sherpa, leader of the
Extreme Everest Expedition 2010, said no one had tried to clear at that
height. "This is the first time we are cleaning the death zone. It is
very difficult and dangerous," said Sherpa, who has climbed Everest
seven times.
The zone earned its name because it is almost impossible to
survive the harsh temperatures and the thin air of such altitudes,
where there is a third as much oxygen as at sea level for more than a
couple of days. Anyone who remains within the zone for longer will
almost certainly perish.
The climbers will use special bags to collect the bodies which
lie between the South Col and the 8,850m (29,035ft) summit before
lowering them down the snow and icefields of the mountain and then
carrying them across the glaciers to base camp. The expedition hopes to
retrieve five bodies, including that of a climber killed two years ago.
Scores of corpses preserved by the freezing temperatures remain on
the mountain, some for decades. "I have seen three corpses lying there
for years," Namgyal said. "We'll bring down the body of a Swiss climber
who died in the mountain in 2008 and cremate it below the base camp,
for which we have got the family's consent."
In 1999 a research expedition found the remains of George Mallory,
a British explorer and mountaineer, who disappeared with ropemate
Andrew Irvine in 1924. Experts have long debated whether it was
possible that the pair had actually reached the summit before
perishing. The find did not provide conclusive evidence. A service was
performed for Mallory and his body left where it was.
More than 4,000 climbers have scaled Everest, which is known as
Chomolungma in local Tibetan language. Climbing has become a key source
of income for Nepal,
a state reduced to poverty by lengthy civil strife and misgovernment.
Not only do expeditions provide employment for thousands but climbers
pay high fees to the Nepali authorities for permission to venture on to
the mountain, providing much-needed hard currency.
Litter on the mountain was a major environmental problem
until the Nepalese government imposed strict rules requiring visitors
to keep the peak clean or risk losing a substantial deposit.
The South Col, from which the attempts to reach the summit are
often launched, had become known as the world's highest rubbish tip,
with the snow littered with empty oxygen bottles, old ropes, food and
the remnants of tents.
"The garbage was buried under snow in the past. But now it has
come out on the surface because of the melting of snow due to global
warming," Namgyal said, adding that some of the rubbish had been on the
mountain since 1953 when Edmund Hillary, who died in 2008, made the
first successful ascent of the mountain with Sherpa Tenzing Norgay.
Earthquake in western China kills 300, say reports
Hundreds trapped beneath rubble after 7.1 quake struck in Yushu county, Qinghai province
A 7.1-magnitude earthquake hit northwest China's Qinghai Province early on Wednesday, the China Earthquake Networks Center said. (Xinhua/Meng Lijing) CCTV
A
photo taken by a mobile phone shows destroyed houses after an
earthquake hit Yushu, northwest China's Qinghai province. Photograph:
Zhang Hongshuan/Xinhua/Reuters
As many as 300 people are dead and many more trapped in rubble after a massive 7.1 quake hit north west China
early today. Chinese state television said the tremor, which struck
around 33km below the surface, has left up to 8,000 injured.
It was one of six to hit Yushu county, Qinghai province this morning.
Army trucks are speeding to the remote area, 490 miles (800km)
away from the provincial capital Xining, to aid rescue and relief
efforts.
Witnesses reported the collapse of many brick and wood buildings.
Some early reports suggested many larger buildings had stood firm. But
the population is relatively scattered making it hard to assess damage.
The main quake sent residents fleeing as it toppled houses made of
mud and wood, said Karsum Nyima, the Yushu county television station's
deputy head of news, speaking by phone with broadcaster CCTV. "In a
flash, the houses went down. It was a terrible earthquake," he said.
"In a small park, there is a Buddhist tower and the top of the tower
fell off.
"Everybody is out on the streets, standing in front of their
houses, trying to find their family members," he said, adding that
school buildings had not collapsed but that students had been evacuated
and were assembled in outdoor playgrounds.
Yushu county is a largely Tibetan area of Qinghai. The province
and other parts of China's north west have suffered repeated tremors in
recent years.
A local government website put the county's population in 2005 at
89,300, a community of mostly herders and farmers. Rescue efforts were
hindered by telecommunications problems, with phone lines down, the
notice said.
State television showed footage of paramilitary police using
shovels to dig around a house with a collapsed wooden roof. A local
military official, Shi Huajie, told state broadcaster CCTV rescuers
were working with limited equipment.
"The difficulty we face is that we don't have any excavators. Many
of the people have been buried and our soldiers are trying to pull them
out with human labour," Shi said. "It is very difficult to save people
with our bare hands."
Wu Yong, a local military chief, said medical workers were also
urgently needed but that roads leading to the airport had been badly
damaged by the quake, creating difficulties for people and supplies to
be flown in.
The epicentre of the first quake was located 235 miles southeast
of Golmud, a large city in Qinghai, at a depth of six miles, the US
Geological Survey said.
Ten minutes later, the area was hit by a magnitude 5.3 quake,
which was followed after two minutes by a temblor measuring 5.2. Both
the subsequent earthquakes were measured at a depth of six miles.
Another quake, measuring 5.8, was recorded at 9.25am.
Two years ago a massive quake in nearby Sichuan left an estimated 90,000 dead or missing.
Rio de Janeiro police occupy slums as city fights back against drug gangs
Polls suggest 'pacification' project welcome in favelas despite reports of draconian tactic.
Police and residents in the Rocinha slum in Rio de Janeiro. Photograph: Vanderlei Almeida/AFP/Getty Images
On a hilltop high above downtown Rio, an ageing white sign clings
to a bullet-pocked water tank that sprouts from the peak of the city's
oldest shantytown. "Rio's state government," it reads. "Making our
people happier."
For years residents of the Morro da Provid๊ncia have stared up at
the sign and its bulletholes the result of shoot-outs between police
and drug traffickers with a mixture of amusement, frustration and
disgust. Accustomed to the iron fist of the drug faction and to
sporadic and deadly police raids, the area's impoverished residents had
little to thank Rio's governors for.
Things may, however, be changing. One recent morning nearly 100
black-clad, special forces operatives swept into the slum, occupying
alleyways and sending drug traffickers scattering.
In the past the police would come to arrest or eliminate gangsters
in a hail of bullets before returning to their base. This time,
however, they stayed. "The police have arrived and the police will
remain," Jos้ Mariano Beltrame, Rio's state security secretary, vowed.
The occupation of the Morro da Provid๊ncia is the latest phase of
a pioneering government "pacification" project that aims to liberate
hundreds of thousands of Rio slum dwellers, replacing violent drug
gangs with a permanent, hearts and minds-style police presence.
Seven of Rio's 1,000-odd favelas have been occupied in the last 18
months as part of the pacification scheme, among them the City of God
favela that gained international notoriety in Fernando Meirelles' hit
film. By the end of 2010 authorities say 59 favelas will have
benefited from the fledgling pacification units, freeing an estimated
210,000 people from the rule of Rio's gangs. Between now and 2016, when
Rio hosts the Olympics, dozens more occupations are planned.
"Once we have filled the first 40 I think we will have achieved a
very large reduction in [levels of] violence in Rio," said Allan
Turnowski, head of Rio's civil police. "It's like attacking the main
cell [in doing that] you weaken all the smaller ones around it."
After decades of lethal clashes between police and traffickers in
which thousands of lives have been lost, the pacification units are
being hailed as a big step forward for the city.
Rio's authorities make little secret of the fact that their aim is
to reclaim hundreds of slums from the control of armed drug gangs,
rather than to stamp out drug trafficking altogether.
Residents of Morro da Provid๊ncia have reacted nervously to the arrival of the police.
Deep in the favela, the middle-aged owner of one tiny street bar
wore an anxious frown. "Young man, are we being occupied?" she
inquired, hours after the special forces had swept into her slum. Asked
whether occupation was a positive change, she said: "We're not allowed
to have an opinion around here. Here we have to be neutral."
Further down the street a teenage girl responded to the same
question with a shout. "Is it good or bad? It's horrible," she said,
before disappearing down one of the favela's many alleyways.
Independent polls have so far shown an overwhelming majority of
slum residents welcome the pacification units. But there have been
sporadic reports of discontent about abusive police searches and a
handful of flare-ups involving protesting residents whom the police
accuse of links to the gangs.
Earlier this month 12 people were injured when a group of alleged
drug dealers set fire to a bus near the City of God slum in an apparent
protest against the pacification scheme. Some human rights groups
complain of draconian policing tactics, pointing to the outlawing of
electronic funk music parties in several occupied slums.
While most of Provid๊ncia's 4,000-odd residents ducked questions
about the new occupation, across town in the Ladeira dos Tabajaras a
favela occupied in January locals were more forthcoming.
"It's great. Things are calm," said Elisa Reis Oliveira, 58, who
has lived in the slum for 25 years. "Before the kids would be playing
outside and suddenly they'd have to start running as soon as there was
a pa-pa-pa," she said, imitating the sound of gunfire. "I just hope it stays like this."
"My policing is done on foot," said Captain Rosana Alves dos
Santos, head of the area's 140-strong pacification unit, as she toured
the slum with her Taurus pistol strapped firmly into its holster. "I
want the residents to trust me and to tell me their problems. It's
contact policing."
Not everything has changed. In January, 77 people were killed here in confrontations with police, a rate of more than two a day.
In
the Morro da Provid๊ncia, meanwhile, police officers had begun
plastering signs of their own on to the community's walls. "A new era
of peace starts now," they read.
Like tiny blue jewels, the western Hawaiian islands glow among the clouds over the Pacific Ocean. The Hawaiian islands are in the north Pacific the larger, eastern islands are probably more well-known, but there are actually eight major islands, as well as many smaller islands and several atolls. Though Hawaii is a US state, the island chain is actually located 1,860 miles from the nearest continent. The islands are the exposed peaks of a volcanic, undersea mountain range Photograph: Aqua/MODIS/NASA
Full-body scan under discussion for U.S. flights criticized 31.12.2009.
BEIJING, Dec. 31 (Xinhuanet)-- The wide use of full-body scanning at airports now being discussed at the White House has set off hot criticism from privacy advocates who call it a "virtual strip search," according to media reports Thursday.
A computer monitor displays the full body scan during a demonstration of passenger screening technology by the Transportation Security Administration, Wednesday, Dec. 30, 2009, at the TSA Systems Integration Facility of the United States.(Xinhua/Reuters Photo)
Ever since the Christmas Day terror attack aboard a Detroit-bound U.S. airliner was thwarted, the security advocates have called for greater use of body scanners that, first used in a U.S. airport in 2007, can find hidden objects that metal detectors can't.
"The advanced imaging technology enhances security because it can detect both metallic and nonmetallic threats hidden on a passenger's body," U.S. Transportation Security Administration (TSA) spokesman Greg Soule said.
Civil libertarians opposed the anatomically revealing technology on all travelers, considering the body scanners an invasion of privacy that is akin to a strip search. The devices detect objects concealed under clothes and can produce detailed images of the body.
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) says it does not trust privacy safeguards, saying the images that depict body shapes and private parts would still exist.
A slightly charred and singed underpants with the explosive packet removed from the crotch is seen in government photos obtained exclusively by ABC News, released to Reuters, Dec. 28, 2009.(Xinhua/Reuters Photo)
"If a celebrity goes through a scanner that kind of image could end up on the Internet," said Jay Stanley, an ACLU privacy expert. "We would certainly all be safer on airlines if we all flew naked," he said.
Addressing privacy concerns, the TSA says faces are blurred on the body scans generated by the agency's machines. Agents who deal directly with passengers do not see the scans, and the agents who review the scans do not see the passengers.
Staff at the U.S. Transporation Security Administration (TSA) Systems Integration Facility, one playing the role of a airline passenger (L) demonstrate the use of Millimeter Wave technology for passenger security screening in Washington, December 30, 2009. The TSA demonstrated two advanced imaging technologies that are used to safely screen passengers for metallic and non metallic threats including weapons, explosives and other objects concealed under layers of clothing without physical contact.(Xinhua/Reuters Photo)
Dutch authorities said Amsterdam's Schiphol Airport, where the Nigerian suspect made a connection, will begin using full-body scanners within three weeks. Also, the airport authority in Nigeria, where AbdulMutallab's flight to Amsterdam originated, announced plans to add body scanners to its security system.
In the United States, 40 of these advanced imaging machines are in use in 19 airports and the use is optional -- passengers can choose to undergo a pat-down instead.
U.S. President Barack Obama could expedite such a deployment because the Department of Homeland Security and TSA don't need legislation from Congress to start using the devices at any of the 560 U.S. airports with scheduled airline service.
U.S. Federal authorities have charged suspect Umar Farouk AbdulMutallab, 23, of Nigeria, with trying to detonate explosives hidden in his underwear on a flight from Amsterdam, Netherlands, to Detroit, Michigan. Editor: Du Xiaodan | Source: Xinhua
Note:I see no objection for compromising time for safety. I have passed through airports where full scanners are used, or where there are multi-security checks, including full body searches. The process is well organised, and delays re minimal. AC.
Drug money saved banks in global crisis, claims UN advisor
Drugs and crime chief says $352bn in criminal proceeds was effectively laundered by financial institutions
Drugs money worth billions of dollars kept the financial system afloat at the height of the global crisis, the United Nations' drugs and crime tsar has told the Observer
Antonio Maria Costa, head of the UN Office on Drugs and Crime, said he has seen evidence that the proceeds of organised crime were "the only liquid investment capital" available to some banks on the brink of collapse last year. He said that a majority of the $352bn (ฃ216bn) of drugs profits was absorbed into the economic system as a result.
This will raise questions about crime's influence on the economic system at times of crisis. It will also prompt further examination of the banking sector as world leaders, including Barack Obama and Gordon Brown, call for new International Monetary Fund regulations. Speaking from his office in Vienna, Costa said evidence that illegal money was being absorbed into the financial system was first drawn to his attention by intelligence agencies and prosecutors around 18 months ago. "In many instances, the money from drugs was the only liquid investment capital. In the second half of 2008, liquidity was the banking system's main problem and hence liquid capital became an important factor," he said.
Some of the evidence put before his office indicated that gang money was used to save some banks from collapse when lending seized up, he said.
"Inter-bank loans were funded by money that originated from the drugs trade and other illegal activities... There were signs that some banks were rescued that way." Costa declined to identify countries or banks that may have received any drugs money, saying that would be inappropriate because his office is supposed to address the problem, not apportion blame. But he said the money is now a part of the official system and had been effectively laundered.
"That was the moment [last year] when the system was basically paralysed because of the unwillingness of banks to lend money to one another. The progressive liquidisation to the system and the progressive improvement by some banks of their share values [has meant that] the problem [of illegal money] has become much less serious than it was," he said.
The IMF estimated that large US and European banks lost more than $1tn on toxic assets and from bad loans from January 2007 to September 2009 and more than 200 mortgage lenders went bankrupt. Many major institutions either failed, were acquired under duress, or were subject to government takeover.
Gangs are now believed to make most of their profits from the drugs trade and are estimated to be worth ฃ352bn, the UN says. They have traditionally kept proceeds in cash or moved it offshore to hide it from the authorities. It is understood that evidence that drug money has flowed into banks came from officials in Britain, Switzerland, Italy and the US. British bankers would want to see any evidence that Costa has to back his claims.
A British Bankers' Association spokesman said: "We have not been party to any regulatory dialogue that would support a theory of this kind. There was clearly a lack of liquidity in the system and to a large degree this was filled by the intervention of central banks."
The plaque on the State House building in Hargeisa, capital of Somaliland, is an oblique commemoration to an event that never occurred. It was built in 1952 for a visit to the then British protectorate by the newly crowned Queen Elizabeth II. The Queen never came. These days the half-ruined structure is known for another reason than as the former seat of gin-sipping British colonial officials.
The grounds, including parkland once laid out as a golf course, have bred domed shelters "bool" they are called thatched with plastic and segments of scavenged cloth. In places, walls have been tiled with panels of flattened cooking oil cans, which in their repetitions resemble Warhol prints. The bools are low, windowless huts through which the harsh light bleeds messily at the sewn seams to illuminate the kicked up dust. The occupants of this camp sit at the far end of the planet's social spectrum from the State House's first intended guest. Not a monarch and her retinue but refugees from war.
The huts are so densely packed together they block the State House from sight. It is barely visible when approaching the camp, but the monument marks the centre of a labyrinth of winding, narrow lanes where cockerels scrabble. When I reach it at last, I find the State House is not occupied itself save for a single wing of outbuildings. Its rooms are open to the sky, floors scattered with detritus. Glassless window frames swing in the wind.
But it is far from empty. Children clamber over walls of square-cut honey-coloured stone, partly demolished by fighting in the city in 1988. They sit on the floor of what once was a grand reception room to play complex games with piles of pale round pebbles, tossed and snatched from the air by competing hands. Outside, a few young men sit on a veranda painted with graffiti, listening to music. They pull jackets over their heads to hide their faces at our approach and warn against photography.
It is a clue to the identity of many living inside the State House camp: the still anxious victims of the war in the south, in Somalia proper, the country from which Somaliland recognised by no other state split in 1991. Victims of the world's worst humanitarian disaster. And conflict, even at a distance from the running gun battles on Mogadishu's streets, imposes its own hierarchies.
The most recent refugees, the poorest, live at the periphery, farthest from the State House itself. Which is why it is surprising to find Sarida Nour Ahmed, aged 31, a recent arrival, occupying one of the building's few habitable rooms, a few metres square. Once used to house the British governor's staff, these days it is roofed with corrugated metal which leaks in the rain. A bool would be much better, she explains.
Sarida fled from Somalia in March, abandoning three of her 10 children in the chaos of flight. "The situation was unbearable. Mortars were landing during the day. At night there was torture, rape and beatings. At first we thought it was because of the Ethiopian invasion. But things got worse. They came to our houses. Robbed and raped." I ask her who? The Shabaab, she says. The Shabaab. The word means literally "the youth". And it is the story of the victims of the Shabaab's continuing war that I have come to the camps of Somaliland to find.
A sick woman pleads for help at the Burao camp, Somaliland. Photograph: Antonio Olmos
Once comprising the northernmost part of Somalia's failed state, for the past two decades Somaliland has proclaimed itself an independent republic. Stable, if not prosperous, it has become a refuge for Somalis from the south, most making their way up north from Mogadishu. For those from Somalia's southernmost towns it is a dangerous journey that can take several months, with long stretches on foot.
The Shabaab was once one of the Islamist militias attached to the Islamic Courts Union, which, in 2006, brought a semblance of peace to a country that had been wracked by years of internecine violence and warlordism. The Courts were routed after a few months by a western-supported Ethiopian invasion. Now the Ethiopians have gone, too, and a fundamentalist hardcore of the Shabaab is resurgent, Somalia's most bitter tormentor Africa's own Taliban.
Its masked men, accused by America of being proxies for al-Qaeda, enforce their own notions of justice, seizing suspected collaborators with the feeble new government from their houses and murdering those it regards as opponents, including dozens of local journalists and aid workers. Its feared and secret sharia courts have sentenced women to be buried and stoned to death for adultery or publicly beaten for infringing strict Islamic dress codes. Somalis say that, beyond the facade of harsh and rigid piety, the group robs and kills and sexually assaults with impunity.
Arriving at the State House camp, accompanied by Oxfam, which is helping to support its residents, I ask to talk to the most recent arrivals from Mogadishu and the south. A group of women lead me through a ruined stone doorframe and across a little yard. It is here, in a dark, bare room smelling of smoke from her cooking fire, that I first meet Sarida. In Mogadishu, she tells me, she and her husband had a "proper house" with five rooms. They owned a little shop and sold cold juices and vegetables in the market. These days she washes clothes and skivvies, when she can, to feed her children. She cannot remember the last time they ate meat.
She describes the violence in fragmented snatches that reflect the chaos in a city where all sides government, African Union peacekeepers, Ethiopians and the Shabaab fight their pitched battles over civilian neighbourhoods, not caring who is killed.
"First the Shabaab fought with the Ethiopians. When the Ethiopians left," recalls Sarida, "we thought then that Somalis would come together. But it didn't happen." What happened instead, she explains, is that the Shabaab moved to impose its values on Somalis in the large areas it controls, bringing more violence as it did. "Women get 90 lashes even for wearing 'light' clothes," says Sarida. "And for not wearing the veil. But the veil costs money. I didn't have money for a veil..." It is a complaint I hear from many women.
Sarida describes the worst day of her life. She does not cry. Not quite. It was a day that began with mortars falling on her neighbour Amina's house and ended with the loss of three of her children. "To see her in pieces " she loses her train of thought for a moment. "Mogadishu is a big city. You used to be able to run to another neighbourhood [to escape the fighting], but the fighting was all over the city. I grabbed the children that were close to me and fled with the clothes I was wearing." Her eldest children, aged 12, 11 and 10 nowhere in sight in the family's panicked impulse to flee were left behind. So too was Sarida's husband, Abdi Khader. I ask the children's names. She says quietly: "Mohammed, Abdi and Hussein. I cheat myself thinking my husband might have got to the children and rescued them."
But Abdi Khader does not know where Sarida ran to. Or where she is living now. Since that day, she hasn't heard from him. "If I could turn back the clock I would have my husband and my children here with me. But I can't go back."
I had first heard about the brutality of the methods of theShabaab from Zam Zam Abdi, a courageous 28-year-old Somali women's rights campaigner forced out of Mogadishu by the group. We had met in London almost a year before. Then, Abdi had told me of the note the group posted on her office door: "Stop what you are doing or we will act. Yes or no?" Abdi knew what it meant. It was a phrase gaining notoriety in Mogadishu even then. She had heard the same message delivered on the radio by a pro-Shabaab Imam, received it in emails and in anonymous calls. The same words had been pinned to the body of one of Abdi's friends, murdered by the Shabaab.
It was Abdi's words that had impelled me to Somaliland to search for the group's victims. And it was to Burao that I was heading Somaliland's second city, and home to the worst of the camps.
The road to Burao takes a sweeping dog leg from Hargeisa down to the coast, before cutting back inland again, crossing an arid plain punctuated by long mesas, hazy in the distance. Visible, too, in places are the remains of Somalia's other wars: wrecked Russian armoured vehicles, rusted and buried to their axles in the sand. Somaliland's camps, however, are a reminder of a more recent conflict: America's war on terror. Far from weakening the Shabaab, the US intervention only appears to have made it stronger.
Beyond the Soviet-built port at Berbera we overtake the Hargeisa bus bound for Mogadishu. It is empty on this leg, but will return full of those fleeing the south. My driver tells me it is good business for those willing to take the risk and drive a truck to Elasha Biyaha, 11 miles from Somalia's capital, at the heart of the Afgoye Corridor, and take on a human cargo desperate to escape.
The Afgoye Corridor. A place synonymous with misery and degradation, hunger and disease. A 20-mile long stretch of road heading west out of Mogadishu, it is home to the world's largest concentration of displaced persons, over half a million living beside the road, many subsisting on boiled leaves. Yet faced with the choice of Mogadishu's gunmen and the horrors of Afgoye, it is Afgoye that many are forced to choose. According to Oxfam, some who end up living there have been displaced three or four times before.
Arriving in Burao I meet one of the luckier ones, Liban Ali Ahmad, 21, who escaped through Elasha Biyaha and the Corridor on a crowded truck a year ago. Lucky, because in his extended family, Liban, a student, could count on two aunts born in Burao who paid for his family to escape and who housed them in the town. Lucky too because he did not have to live in the Corridor, only navigate one of the world's most dangerous roads.
Liban is studying in his green-painted bedroom when I call to visit. He is tall and slim, with sideburns shaved into long slender blades that follow his cheekbones. There are English books stacked in one corner. He cannot afford the fees for he local university where he would like to do a course in business management, so he teaches himself in his room, furnished only with a mattress.
In Mogadishu, he tells me, his four-times widowed mother was a "khat lady" selling kilo "trees" of the narcotic stems imported from Ethiopia, where it is grown. Her business paid for a rented house in Wada Jir district, close to the airport. "It was bad there because the war was everywhere," Liban remembers. He seems calm as he tells his story, until I notice his hands held in his lap, fingers weaving an invisible cat's cradle of anxiety. After he finished secondary school Liban worked as a private tutor, teaching children at home who could not go to school Arabic, maths and Somalian.
"I tried for two or three months," he says. "It didn't work out." The families of the children Liban was teaching were fleeing the city, until most of his neighbourhood was empty. "There was supposed to be a ceasefire. But there was fighting and the schools were all closed. So my brother said he wanted to see if the school was open. It wasn't. He climbed into a tree near to our house to play. That's when he was shot."
He calls out into the corridor for 14-year-old Ayanle, a shy and skinny teenager, blind in one white and pupil-less eye. Liban gently helps his brother out of his shirt and then a T-shirt, to show where the bullet went in, piercing Ayanle's chest and bursting through his back. The wounds have healed and puckered to small, dark deformities. "Recently he became sick again," Liban explains: "Because of the bullet." Even after Ayanle's shooting the family tried to stay in their home. "Those six months were terrifying. Even when the children came here they were still terrified. They would ask: 'When are the bullets coming?'"
In Wada Jir they could not go to the marketplace for days. The residents within his neighbourhood were given a 10-minute warning by the Shabaab when the fighting would begin. Told not to move. Not to leave their houses.
"Finally we were trapped in our house for seven days. The smallest children were lying like they were dead. We couldn't give them water. Not fit for humans to drink. In the end I risked my life to go out to get water and something for the kids to eat. We had been discussing it for ages, whether we should escape. That time those seven days were the final exam. We decided to leave."
Almost the last to leave their neighbourhood, the family headed for Elasha Biyaha and the Afgoye Corridor with $300, donated by an uncle, to pay for their escape. It was left to Liban to arrange it. He hired a taxi first to take him through the fighting to the Corridor, to hire a truck to take the family out. "It was risky. We left while there was still fighting going on. Some of the vehicles hit mines and exploded. You either leave safely or end like this," he adds bleakly.
The camps in Burao are ugly places. There are no schools orhealth facilities. Not even proper sanitation. Privately owned, the residents are charged to occupy their huts and draw water from the solitary well. The 15 May camp is the worst: its huts border a field covered with rubbish, where camels are herded beneath the trees. On one visit I hear the sound of drumming, and enter a hut to find it crowded with men and women at a Sufi ceremony to drive spirits from a woman kneeling on the floor, pungent incense wafting through the hut.
In her bool nearby, Quresh Ise Nour has a baby wrapped in a pink blanket in her arms, born a week before on the road to Burao, hair slicked wet with sweat. Tradition demands that Quresh stays indoors, confined, for 40 days. Without a husband to support her, she must rely on other women from the camp, who go to Burao to beg, to bring her food. When the pickings are slim, or non-existent, Quresh cannot eat, cannot produce enough breast milk and her baby goes hungry. Her hut is a new one; the older ones, with their multiple layers of fabric, are better, she explains, because they are cooler.
Quresh is the camp's most recent arrival. Her husband was killed in the fighting in Mogadishu. "He was a casual worker. He left in the morning to go to work with his wheelbarrow. He was away for only four hours," she says, not quite believing what could happen in so short a period of time. "Some friends he used to work with brought his body back in his own barrow. His name was Mohammad Hassan Ali." Fleeing Mogadishu, she ran with her children to Afgoye.
"You would always hear the bullets. Then everyone would try to run. When you would get back to your home the mortar shells would land on the huts. It is because the Shabaab would use the bools for their defences. The government forces would come in vehicles and uniforms. The Shabaab would be in civilian clothes with rifles and RPGs. They controlled the area we were in. They would mine all the routes that they believed the government troops might enter by. You can't tell anyone," she explains, seriously. "They ask all the time: 'Where are you going?' Their faces are covered with scarves so you only see their eyes. Most of the time I stayed indoors." Because of the mines, the African Union troops would not come into the camp. "They would come close and mortar where we lived, so the Shabaab would say: 'These are bad people'. But with the Shabaab you never got kind words."
I start to understand how the Shabaab work. Others tell me of masked young men with megaphones walking by the houses, shouting out the rules. I hear stories of men taken from their homes and later found shot. All blamed on the Shabaab. A woman called Busharo tells me how the men arrived in her hut at night asking for her husband. Not finding him, they burned down her home.
Quresh says: "If you don't have a hijab, the Shabaab come to you. They came to me. I told them my husband was dead and I had no money. They ran into my house. I thought there must have been fighting. They said: "Woman, why are you not wearing a veil?" There were two of them with a whip made from woven tyre rubber. They hit me on the back and buttocks. Even now you can see the marks. A month later I left."
The stories of the Shabaab's cruelties accumulate as I tour the camps. One man tells me how they stopped him returning from his work and stole the fruit he had bought intended for his children, warning him not to resist. They said his life was worth more than some fruit. I hear the story of how the Shabaab tried to drag a neighbour's wife out of his house to rape her. How he was shot when he tried to stop them. Patterns emerge. Visits by day and night by armed men seeking friends and family, often accompanied by a press-ganged neighbour or passer-by, snatched from the street, and ordered to indicate the house they seek.
Even as they tell their tales, the fear of the Shabaab still clings to these people. I ask for names, descriptions of the perpetrators, even nicknames they might have given individual Shabaab fighters. But no one is comfortable to say "it was this person". The reason, I am told at last, is that there are Shabaab sympathisers in the camps, perhaps even among those who gather to listen to the interviews in curious groups.
There is one man, in particular, who I am looking for, Abdi Abdullahi Jimale, a 38-year-old mechanic from Mogadishu and sometime farmer who came to Burao nine months before. I already know the bare bones of his awful story: how he lost four of his children to hunger and violence. These days he makes a living through odd jobs and a few days' work at the local tannery when he can. Otherwise he sends his girls into Burao to beg. Abdi calls the Shabaab "al-Qaeda". "The Shabaab are everywhere among the people. They take what you have and leave you empty except for sorrow. When they started appearing they would say, 'You can't watch videos at home. You can't listen to music.' When the fighting came I lost two of my children. I didn't even have a chance to bury their bodies." He tells me that their names were Osman, aged four, and Mohammed, five. "I was sitting in my house when I heard the bullets. A little later a shell fell on my house. I carried some of the children and my wife the others, then we ran away." Their ordeal was not yet over. "I had two other children who died on the way to Baladweyne. They were small children.
We walked a long way and they were very tired. They were one and three, and we were walking for eight days. We had put the children on a donkey cart at first, but some people took the donkey cart and the things we had in it." The rest of the family was saved through the intervention of a group of nomadic pastoralists who killed a goat for them to eat
I am in my hotel in Burao when a text messagecomes in. There has been a fire at the State House camp. The details change. Six huts destroyed, the message says at first, then later 12. A child has been killed. We head straight to Hargeisa and the State House. It is a girl of five who has been killed. The fire jumped from bool to bool in a matter of seconds, the flames enveloping the dry panels of fabric, collapsing it upon her. There is a clearing, now, among the huts
Someone has handed those who have lost their homes brightly coloured plastic buckets, to collect what is left of their possessions. The women hunt among the ashes for pots and pans, but there is almost nothing left but an accumulation of flaking ash. The shelters have been reduced in places to nothing more than a stubby spine of charcoal nubs, all that is left of poles that once supported them. A few torn pages from school books are blowing among the ashes.
★
Ismael, the Islamist footsoldier, explains why he joined al-Shabaab
(Jack Hill for The Times)
Ismael Mohamed, 21, lost a leg fighting with the Islamist insurgents al-Shabaab, but has now renounced violence and is afraid to go home
Tristan McConnell
In our country there are three paths: you can join al-Shabaab, you can join [the government forces] or you can go abroad, said Ismael Mohamed. Me, I dont have money to go away so I join al-Shabaab.
Ismael, 21, is a typical Islamist footsoldier. He is neither a jihadi nor an extremist; he loves God and Manchester United. He is a young Muslim with an education his English is excellent but no opportunities in a country that has been at war for as long as he has been alive.
Civil war led to the collapse of Somalias last Government in 1991. The rebels then turned on one another in a fight for power. Many Somali youngsters know nothing of life without war.
Al-Shabaabs leaders are militant nationalists and Islamic extremists but the rank-and-file fighters are hired guns, conscripts or volunteers. Ismael joined up during last years failed rains when food was scarce and al-Shabaab was in the ascendancy weeks earlier it had launched a fresh offensive against the Transitional Federal Government (TFG). I didnt have anywhere to stay or anything to do. My friends, some of them were al-Shabaab and they would tell me that TFG is not Muslim, but al-Shabaab is Muslim, he explained.
President Sharif Ahmeds US and Western support marks him out as an infidel to al-Shabaab. He is kaffir, said Ismael.
In Mogadishu, Ismael lived with other young al-Shabaab fighters in a shared house in Bakara Market, an Islamist stronghold and no-go area for government forces and African Union peacekeepers (Amisom). He would wait for a call then take up his AK47 and go into battle. I was mujahidin for real, he said proudly.
During a gunfight on the streets of Mogadishu, four months after joining al-Shabaab, a mortar explosion mangled his leg and peacekeepers took him to their tented hospital close to the sea. Sitting on a camp bed, he rubbed the bandaged stump where his left leg used to be. My leg, it is a small wound only, he said with an ironic smile.
Ismael is grateful to Amisom for saving his life and has renounced al-Shabaab. What I believed before and what I believe now are different. I felt that Amisom was my enemy but they were very helpful to me. As he spoke he turned a leather-bound Koran over and over in his hands. He has given up the violence of the Islamist insurgency, but remains a pious Muslim. Soon he will be discharged; he would go back to his mothers house in a district called Medina, but he is worried.
TFG (Transitional Federal Government) troops are there and they know me very well; maybe they will kill me. And if I go back in Bakara maybe al-Shabaab will kill me. I would like my country to be at peace but I dont know how ... Me, I cannot see any peace, just fighting.
A government soldier patrols the devastated frontline in Mogadishu. Photograph: Ghaith Abdulahad for the Guardian
On a side street off Mogadishu's Wadnaha Road frontline a young
officer is explaining the unwritten rules of the city's intractable
civil war as his men exchange fire with an unseen enemy.
The fighters shooting at him are from the Hizb al-Islam, he explains. He knows this because they fight longer than al-Shabab, the other main Islamist group besieging Somalia's
tiny government-held enclave, but also because they told him. "We have
friends there. They tell us before they leave their base that they are
going to attack. When they want to fire mortars they tell us so we can
take cover."
If the conflict that has turned Mogadishu into a virtual no-go
zone for 19 years occasionally resembles a grim farce, there is nothing
farcical about the scene around us.
Nearby lies an array of flip flops in different shapes and sizes
and always in singles: blues, reds, purples, tiny plastic ones with
flower designs and large leather ones attesting to previous skirmishes,
advances and retreats. A jungle of trees and shrubs has taken over the
deserted street so that the soldiers have to push the branches with
their elbows and guns to make a path. Houses and shops are shattered,
empty and riddled with bullet holes.
Somalia is the world's invisible conflict, and perhaps its least comprehensible.
Since January last year, when Ethiopia
pulled out of the country, the Islamist government of Sharif Ahmed has
been locked in an attritional struggle with al-Shabab, a more radical
offshoot of the Islamic Courts movement, the alliance of tribal sharia
courts which once controlled most of southern Somalia. The government
is also under attack from Hizb al-Islam, many of whom fought alongside
Ahmed against the Ethiopia.
Al-Shabab and Hizb al-Islam control most of Mogadishu and south
and central Somalia, having squeezed the internationally backed
government into a sliver of land defended by an African Union force.
But it is hard to keep up with the shifting frontlines of this
conflict: when I was in Mogadishu last May the government controlled
all of Wadnaha and Factory roads, the main arteries that cross the city.
Soon after I left, the commanders and their troops in that area
joined the opposition, and the government lost three miles of territory
including the camps at the ministry of defence and the stadium.
When the warlord Yousuf Neda Adi switched sides again this time
rejoining the government with his troops the government line
stretched back and gained another few hundred metres. But Adi now
believes the government may have been behind a recent assassination
attempt against him.
But there is more at stake here than a few square miles of
territory. Al-Shabab have established themselves as the Somali
franchise of al-Qaida,
aspiring to be named as al-Qaida in Somalia just as with jihadi
groups in Yemen and Morocco. They are imposing a regime of extreme
sharia law on the areas they control that makes the Taliban seem
moderate. Western security experts, Somalis living abroad and local
fighters say the country is fast becoming the favoured destination for
wannabe jihadis.
The addition of the whine of US drones to Mogadishu's symphony of
tank, mortar and machine gun fire is evidence of the deep anxiety the
conflict is causing in Washington and other western capitals. As one
minister told me over a breakfast of goat liver, bananas, papayas,
chapattis and sweet milk tea: "For the first time in many years the
international community is interested in Somalia, not because of our
suffering but because of al-Qaida. The British and the Americans are
interested in helping us because they see the anarchy in Mogadishu is
hitting them back home."
Beheading video
Abdey Qadir is a tall figure with small, sunken eyes and a thick
beard that grows only under his chin, giving him the appearance of a
fierce goat. He is an intelligence officer in the Amniyat or security division of al-Shabab.
We meet in a room on the government side of the frontline. He
pulls a Chinese mobile phone from his pocket, fiddles for a bit, then
holds it in his giant hands and shows me a grainy bluish film.
A man dressed in a white shirt and dark trousers is lying on his
stomach on the ground. He is blindfolded with a black cloth, his arms
tied behind his back. Another man is standing astride him, one foot
pinning his shoulder to the ground. The victim's feet shake but he is
silent and his mouth is closed.
There are trees around and the person who is filming shouts "Allahu
akbar. Allahu akbar." The "executioner" pulls the man's short hair up,
the head lifts, he stretches his right arm under his neck and starts
cutting from left to right.
In short fast moves, the knife moves up and down, in and out. The body
shakes and a pool of blood flows calmly and gathers under the head. The
executioner pulls the knife to the right and then goes back to the
start and cuts deeper this time to separate the head.
The film stops and there is a thick cold silence in the room. "We
killed him because he was a spy," Abdey says calmly. "We captured him
trying to cross from the government lines."
Qadir explains that the practice of beheading and removing limbs,
for which al-Shabab have become notorious, has been an important
element in establishing the group's grip on large areas of the country.
"One of the reasons for our strong name is not only the war, it's
the strong fierce rule that is based on cutting heads as punishments
for the crimes," he says. "We have gained respect. We implement a
strong rule that no one can deviate from which has also made us very
popular with Arab and other mujahideen. We have courts all the time
that implement sharia, but when we are in the middle of war and the
fighter captures the traitors and the apostate soldiers of the
government then we implement the sharia immediately and cut the head."
Qadir tells me proudly that he doesn't himself carry a gun. "My
duties are to bring news, watch the people who move weapons to the
government side from the weapons markets and find the enemies of
al-Shabab in our area To kill people you don't need a gun Not
always."
I ask him why he fought a government that imposed sharia on
Somalia and is led by one of their former allies in the Islamic courts
movement. "According to our beliefs Somalia was never an Islamic
country it has to be liberated from the apostasy. After that we move
to Kenya, Ethiopia, Djibouti The resistance never stops at specific
borders."
Al-Shabab's origins date to the mid-1990s when a group of militant
jihadis split from the Itehad al-Islami, the main Islamist organisation
at the time, in Somalia and later joined a loose alliance known as the
Islamic courts.
The more militant elements in the alliance gave Ethiopia, ever
nervous about the Islamist presence on its doorstep, the pretext to
invade.
Ethiopia's occupation was backed by the US but after a war of
insurgency led by the courts alliance, the Ethiopians withdrew, handing
security to the African Union.
In a clan-based society such as Somalia where it's not uncommon to
hear someone say of a close cousin: "We meet in the 10th grandfather"
or approximately 300 years ago the militias are tribal; the forging
and breaking of alliances happens according to tribal interests. Even
the parliament is a tribal entity based on a sub-sub-clan
representation.
Foot soldiers
Al-Shabab's success like other Islamist organisations can
partly be attributed to their "modern structure", based more on merit
rather than tribal loyalties. Beliefs, rituals and loyalty to the
commander of the faithful replace the traditional loyalties.
Their foot soldiers are young men, radicalised by years of war,
many from the marginalised tribes of the farming south that have been
dominated for the past two decades by the strong pastoralist tribes.
Their tribal elders can no longer offer any resemblance of respect.
"Most of the new recruits joining us now are the zealous young,
their hearts are filled with passion and zeal, who can't wait to face
the enemy. They are 14, 15, 16," said Qadir.
"They empower the young," a writer in Mogadishu who lives in
al-Shabab-controlled Bakara market told me. "They go to the young, give
them power, the power to face that rotten structure of the tribe, power
in the shape of a gun. Power as self esteem and belief This is why
they succeed. Now I am worried about my own young brother."
With power, discipline and structure, al-Shabab managed to provide
"security" to the local population, making it possible for people to
safely leave their houses, go shopping, do business and, unlike
government soldiers who are known to be little better than looters and
criminals, their fighters enjoy a good reputation.
They also levy taxes from businesses and farmers and even local herders.
"We tax the people, the companies, the farmers and the herders.
But we don't use the word tax. Instead we use the term aid. We also
control some ports and airports that give us revenues.
"The big money transfer companies we go to them once a month
they pay between ten thousand dollars and twenty during the war, at the
time of peace few thousands only," says Qadir.
Al-Shabab is in nominal alliance with Hizb al-Islam but they often
clash with each other over control of "liberated" areas and a war of
assassination is going on between the two parties. Recently they have
started to outbid each other on radicalism. When Hizb banned radios in
Mogadishu from broadcasting music, al-Shabab issued a statement a week
later banning schools from ringing bells. After al-Shabab started
getting support from al-Qaida in Yemen and other jihadi groups, Hizb
called on Osama bin Laden to come to Mogadishu.
Foreign backing
Just as the government receives military and financial support
from Ethiopia, Djibouti, the EU and US, al-Shabab also look abroad for
money, weapons and fighters.
"The government takes support from the west so we take support from our brothers the muhajiroon
- immigrants," says Qadir. "Some are part of the fighting brigade, some
don't leave their hiding places. They work in manufacturing explosives
and strategy and those are not seen.
"They are Asians, Yemenis and Arabs with American passports, but
there are also many Africans Kenyans, Tanzanians and Moroccans." A
large number of the muhajiroon arriving in Mogadishu are Somalis with
western passports, he says. Some of them went on to become suicide
bombers.
"We take films of the shelling and the bombing by the government
and the African Union, and we show to the young in the diaspora and
they come here enraged and passionate," he says. "We have our
supporters in America, Australia and in Europe. Their duty is to
recruit men and bring them to Somalia. The young men, most of them
haven't seen war in their lives, go to military training for six months
and then they fight."
Another commander with Hezb al-Islam explains the dynamics of the
different foreign fighters flocking to Somalia: "Most are from Africa
Nigerians, Sudanese and Zanzibaris. There are Arabs also, most of them
Yemenis, and a few Asians. And there are the Somalis from Britain,
Holland, Sweden and Norway." Many of the foreigners have been trained
and able to instruct Somali fighters and returning Somalis in tactics
and first aid. "The foreigners, especially from Pakistan and Yemen,
have a very high training. They also teach us how to make explosive
belts how to plant time bombs in walls and under the floor." Later a
Hizb al-Islam commander tells me his group was also attracting fighters
from abroad. "Now the foreigners coming are Arabs from Europe, from the
US and from Yemen. They are very experienced fighters in directing
mortar and artillery fire and very good snipers.
"The Somalis are better in open field attacks but the foreigners are better in sniping and artillery."
Many things have changed in Mogadishu over the last year. Gone are
the plastic chairs in the presidential office and in have come wooden
chairs with leather padding. The air-conditioned office is by far the
coldest place in Mogadishu; a sweater is needed to stop you from
shivering, while outside the sweltering heat envelops everything and everyone.
Even the president looks happier. The trappings of power seem to
suit him. He no longer carries the world-weary look I saw when he took
office last year. His face slips easily into a confident smile. He
wears a thin, gold watch encrusted with glittering gems.
But Ahmed, who was described by Hillary Clinton as "our best
hope", now rules only over a hilltop compound, the Villa Somalia, and a
few adjacent streets. His government is on the verge of collapse, the
parliament is split and infighting and corruption are paralysing the
administration. Officers in the army say that they haven't been paid
for months, the soldiers say they have no food to eat, and a major arms
dealer told me that senior officers sell him their newly supplied guns
and ammunition.
"We have learned a lot in the past year," says Ahmed, his fingers
flipping the turquoise stones of a prayer bead as he speaks. "We don't
think just in terms of military offensives. We think about humanitarian
services, of understanding the people and orienting them towards their
sacred responsibility of their holy duty towards their government."
Recruits
A few days after meeting him, I head back to the presidential
compound to attend the army day ceremonies. On one side of the hall are
dozens of newly trained recruits, all in uniforms and boots supplied by
the foreign powers that trained them, from France to Sudan and Djibouti.
On the other side are officers former officers from the army,
militia commanders and warlords. In between are ministers, dignitaries
and more warlords.
Thickset bodyguards in sunglasses lead the president into the
room. A brass orchestra strikes up the national anthem and everyone
stands. A thin and elderly officer, carrying a rusted ceremonial sword
and wearing a peeling red helmet, goose steps to the front of the hall,
saluting the president and the flag with his sword.
On the wall at the front a projector shows a film in sepia shades
of a Somali army parade, men dressed in camouflage or beige uniforms
marching in perfect rhythm, followed by tanks, trucks and artillery
pieces, and planes passing in the sky, accompanied by the commentary of
a deep-voiced man. The image moves from the parade ground to the stands
to show the former president Siad Barre in dark sunglasses.
At this, the hall erupts in applause and cheers for the former
dictator. The film was from the late 1970s, when Somalia had one of the
strongest armies in Africa, explains one of the officers next to me.
After an hour of speeches and as the president takes the podium, I
stand outside watching a scuffle break out among the newly trained
soldiers over the scraps of leftover food from the dignitaries' lunch
inside. The Ugandan soldiers standing guard at the gate attempt to keep
order but soon gave up.
Then a big explosion rocks the building. The insurgents have
started shelling the Villa Somalia compound just as the president
begins to speak. The soldiers keep fighting for the scraps of food but
a Ugandan tank parked close to the hall starts firing back at the
insurgents' positions in the crowded markets of the city underneath.
Six shells whoosh from the tank.
Eighteen people were killed and 64 injured from the shelling, I
was told the next day when I went to Madina hospital. The director and
the staff had spent the night in the operation room. "We did 35
operations during the night," the director tells me.
Just another day in Mogadishu's very uncivil war.
This article was
amended on Tuesday 8 June 2010. In the sentence ''When they want to
fire mortars they tells us so we can take cover." the word tells has
been corrected to tell.
Somalia: In the market for war
Arms dealer explains how steady supply of weapons means there is no victor and vanquished in civil war - and may never be
Government soldiers on the front lines in Mogadishu. Photograph: Ghaith Abdulahad for the Guardian
Farah, a former commander in the Islamic courts union, is now a
respected arms dealer in the Huwaika market in Mogadishu. Overweight,
he walks with the aid of two mismatched crutches, after losing a leg
when a mortar shell exploded next to him. ("Ethiopia mortar whoosh
bang," he says.)
His accounts of how each side in the civil war in Somalia comes to be armed make clear just how grim are the prospects for the country.
"The Ethiopians are arming the Sufi militias; the Europeans and US
are arming the government; the Eritreans are arming the Hizb; and the
government officers sell us their weapons, and we sell it to al-Shabab."
Like a business strategist Farah explains that the economy in Mogadishu is part of a bigger picture.
"A Kalashnikov used to be $150, now it's $500 and it will
increase. When there is heavy war your profits are high everyone goes
to the market to buy."
But when he starts unravelling the network of arms supplies, the
picture becomes more complicated. The steady supply of arms means there
is no victor and no vanquished and probably never will be. Each time
one side is about to lose the battle, a neighbouring country or other
foreign power provides them with enough weapons to keep fighting,
ensuring there is no end in sight.
"Ethiopia is the biggest supplier to anyone who wants to fight
al-Shabab. Anyone who forms a front to fight the Shabab gets weapons
from Ethiopia."
"Ahlu Sunna (the Sufis) in the middle regions go to Ethiopia for
weapons, Eritrea was a big supplier for the Islamic courts during the
Ethiopian invasion but they stopped, now they send little shipments to
the Hizb. From Yemen, merchants bring small ammunitions of weapons,
some pistols, nothing more.
"The Shebab they buy it from the market," he says rubbing his
thumb and index finger together. The big military officers, they sell
their ammunitions and guns in bulk, but the small soldiers can't sell
their weapons unless they are not going back to barracks."
"When the people are poor, when the soldier's wife says they have no food they come to me and sell their weapons."